Featured Restaurants

Bars & Pubs

Pool Bars

Now a vacation isn’t complete without fantastic dining, and that’s something the people of Put-In-Bay know very well. That’s why Put-In-Bay has an impressive selection of excellent restaurants, offering more food options per square foot than any other place in Ohio!

Mr. Ed’s Bar & Grille

Mr Ed's Bar and Grille is a crowd favorite at Put-in-Bay.  This famous Put-in-Bay hotspot is not only one of the best places to grab a drink, it's also the new home of Cameo Pizza. Cameo offers their specialty pizzas, chicken wings and more out of Mr. Ed's kitchen. Diners can eat inside the bar, or opt for lunch on the outdoor patio.  So, at Mr Ed's Bar and Grille there are options for everybody.   The location of Mr. Ed's is ideal, on the main street of Put-in-Bay.  Furthermore, the Delaware Avenue block has the majority of the shops, restaurants and... More Information

Quick Info:

272 Delaware Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456, United States

Joe’s Bar & Restaurant

Joe's Bar and Restaurant is a local favorite hangout.  The atmosphere is inviting, putting patrons at ease.  Guests can expect to leave refreshed from Joe's. Finding the location is easy.  Joe's is located on the corner of Meechen Road and Catawba Avenue.  South Bass Island State Park is a short walk away.  The building is very distinguishable with a striking red exterior.  Moreover, the structure has a rich and lively history.  Previously, the space was used as a press house for grapes.  The wine making traditions of Put-in-Bay run deep.  Here, the Doller press house, was integral in the wine... More Information

Quick Info:

1400 Catawba Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456, United States

Green Room at Mr. Ed’s

The Green Room at Mr. Ed's is the premier spot for late night entertainment.  Dance the night away under the stars at this favorite rooftop bar.  Also, enjoy sweeping views of DeRivera Park and the downtown Put-in-Bay harbor.  Get with the beat, as the best DJ's in the area keep the scene jumping. Green Room Location The home bar of this great Put-in-Bay hot spot is Mr. Ed's Bar and Grille.  Mr. Ed's has an outstanding location on the main strip.  Furthermore, the majority of the best Put-in-Bay Attractions and Shopping options are a short walk away.  Also, the Jet... More Information

Quick Info:

300 Delaware Avenue, Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456, United States

MIST Pool Bar

MIST Pool Bar is the island's hottest wet spot!  Here, guests can immerse themselves in the beautiful setting.  The sounds of the waterfalls crashing sets the tone.  Swim right up for a hand crafted cocktail while enjoying the scene.  Weekends feature outstanding local DJ's spinning tunes.  The scene is electric!  Weekdays offer a more relaxed vibe, a respite from the hustle of daily life. Be sure to check the Entertainment Schedule, as great acts play on the pool deck throughout the season. MIST Pool Bar Location MIST is located behind Mr. Ed's Bar and Grill.  Mr. Ed's is situated in... More Information

Quick Info:

272 Delaware Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456, United States


Subway is the place to eat fresh on Put-in-Bay.  The location is in the lobby of the Commodore Resort.  The smells of freshly baked bread lure in customers.  Additionally, the variety of selections and value make this a visitor favorite.  Therefore, to save some funds during a Put-in-Bay visit, Subway is a viable option. The Commodore Resort is situated just behind Mr. Ed's Bar and Grille.  So, to find this sandwich shop from Delaware Ave., just look for the Subway sign in front of Mr. Ed's.  Then, walk right down the alley for a sub made to order.  The choices... More Information

Quick Info:

272 Delaware Ave, Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456, United States

Cameo Pizza

Cameo Pizza of Put-in-Bay prides themselves on using fresh ingredients. The crust and sauce is fresh, made daily.   So, diners can expect a fresh and tasty pizza every time.  Additionally, Cameo's offers subs, wraps, salads and more.  There is a reason this has become a staple of Put-in-Bay. The location of this favored eatery is in downtown Put-in-Bay on Catawba Avenue.  Put-in-Bay Town Hall, the Put-in-Bay Police Department and the Lake Erie Islands Historical Museum are just steps away.  Guests can opt to visit this location for carry out service.  Otherwise, delivery service is available.  Delivery hours plunge deep into... More Information

Quick Info:

438 Catawba Avenue, Put-in-Bay, OH, United States

Last Resort Engine Company

Welcome to Put-in-Bay, Ohio. Have you ever looked at a firetruck and thought to yourself "I'd love to have myself a beer in there?" Well look no further, because Last Resort Engine Company is the bar of your dreams! Last Resort Engine Company This awesome Put-in-Bay bar is literally a firetruck turned into a bar. The truck itself is a 1980's "LaFrance Pumper" and is actually still working condition despite its age. Although, now that its tank has been removed, it won't be fighting fires anytime soon. Another cool thing about the bar is the way they've been able to... More Information

Quick Info:

432 Catwaba Ave

Biergarten at the Boathouse

The Biergarten at the Boathouse is a new and great addition to the Put-in-Bay Bar Scene.  Here, guests can choose from a fine selection of German beers and food.  Order an authentic German bratwurst and wash it down with a stein of authentic brew.  Other food choices include Bavarian pretzels and savory potato cakes.  A comfortable outdoor seating area is in the rear, beckoning guests for relaxation. Biergarten at the Boathouse Location Downtown Put-in-Bay is home to the Biergarten.  Furthermore, this is the first pub guests will encounter upon disembarking the Jet Express.  So, for the quickest beverage off the... More Information

Quick Info:

194 Hartford Avenue, Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456, United States

Boardwalk Restaurant

The Boardwalk Restaurant has many tasty Put-in-Bay dining options.  Within the complex, there are a variety of food offerings.  Most notably, is their Lobster Bisque.  This restaurant is hailed as the Lobster Bisque Capital of Ohio. The Boardwalk has something for everyone. The waterfront location affords guests with expansive views of Lake Erie and the downtown docks.  Additionally, sweeping vistas of downtown Put-in-Bay are sure to inspire.  This building on the shore is very distinguishable. Boardwalk Restaurant- Dining Choices Galore! The Boardwalk Restaurant is comprised of several different eateries.  On the main deck there are three distinct eateries.  First, the... More Information

Quick Info:

341 Bayview Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH, United States

Boathouse Restaurant

The Boathouse Bar and Grill on Put-in-Bay is ready to serve you.  They have been offering delectable meals and cold drinks for over 50 years.  Additionally, the Boathouse is the proud home of outstanding island entertainment.  Great eats and great bands is their motto and they certainly live up to it. The location is nothing short of prime.  Located in downtown Put-in-Bay on Hartford Avenue, the Boathouse is near all of the action.  Also, the Jet Express dock and downtown marina is just a short walk away.  So, this is a favorite among boaters due to the proximity to the... More Information

Quick Info:

218 Hartford Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH, United States

No matter the craving, be it cozy pub grub, fine dining, zesty Mexican, or fresh seafood, Put-In-Bay has it all, including the perfect spot for a quick slice of pizza! With options from early breakfast to late-night snacks, you’re always covered. Some of the most cherished moments with family and friends happen over tasty meals, whether it’s a holiday feast, birthday dinner, or just a casual get-together.
An incredible meal can take your vacation experience to a whole new level, especially when shared with loved ones. At Put-In-Bay, our dining options cater to every taste, from laid-back restaurants to a bit more upscale, we cover every meal imaginable. The real challenge lies in exploring as many of these tempting Put-In-Bay restaurants as possible during your visit! Keep reading to discover all the amazing dining choices waiting for you at the Bay!

Frosty's Bar Put-in-Bay Restaurants

Unique Put-in-Bay Restaurants and Cuisine

As you make your culinary journey across the Lake Erie Islands, where local and authentic flavors are found at every turn. From the simplicity of fresh lake fish savored with a stunning view of the Bay to the relaxed yet upscale feel of eateries like Goat Soup and Whiskey, the dining experiences at Put-In-Bay cater to all tastes. Imagine enjoying a different Put-In-Bay restaurant for every meal, each offering its own unique look and flavor!
Wondering about reservations? Most dining spots here welcome walk-ins, so there’s no need to reserve a table in advance!
Dive into the finest Lake Erie catches, such as Walleye and Perch, served up as fresh as you’d in the world’s most famous restaurants. As the evenings set in, the island’s entertainment scene comes alive. Enjoy beautiful dances, traditional island guitar music, and the rhythms of steel drums. The energetic crowd interactions with late-night DJs in Put-In-Bay’s clubs and bars are not to be missed out on either. And if you’re curious about the number of bars in Put-In-Bay, Ohio, well there are over three dozen, each with their own amazing vibes.


Seafood and Concerts

Sitting in the shallowest of Great Lakes, Put-In-Bay has local fisherman who set out before dawn, often near the iconic lighthouse. Their fresh catches contribute very significantly to Put-In-Bay restaurants’ reputation for having some of the area’s finest food. These restaurants pride themselves on serving freshly caught seafood, masterfully prepared by local chefs using ingredients from the island’s gardens. Many restaurants grow their own herbs and vegetables, making sure everyone has a fresh and green dining experience.
The food options don’t just end there though! For those who are looking for faster service, there’s a range of options including Subway, the Chicken Patio, Cameo’s Pizza, and the Burrito Stand.
The island’s food appeal even links to its exciting event scene. The annual Bash on the Bay country concert is a highlight, offering fair-style food alongside performances. Past lineups have included renowned artists like Toby Keith, Rascal Flatts, and Kid Rock. Moreover, local hotels like the Islander Inn and the Bayshore Resort boast unique dining experiences, enhancing the culinary scenery of Put-in-Bay.

An additional perk for visitors is the potential savings when booking accommodations directly, avoiding platforms like Airbnb or VRBO. This saving can be a bonus for enjoying the diverse and delicious dining options on the island. Put-in-Bay truly offers a blend of culinary excellence and lively entertainment, making it a must-visit destination.


Pepperoni Pizza

Love fresh food?

Put-in-Bay has an impressive number of restaurants; over forty dining and drinking venues to be exact. Conveniently located near both the Miller Ferry and Jet Express, your next delicious meal is always just a short walk or ride away. This page highlights a few of these culinary gems, but for a more detailed guide, be sure to visit PutinbayDining.com. Alternatively, for a local’s recommendation, start a conversation with a Put-in-Bay taxi driver – their suggestions might pleasantly surprise you!

Among the island’s dining hotspots is the Upperdeck, famous for its seafood offerings. Here, you can taste local favorites like the celebrated lobster bisque, traditionally prepared and served in a hearty sourdough bread bowl. Located on the Boardwalk off Bayview Ave, Upperdeck isn’t just about great food; it offers a spectacular view. From its viewpoint, you can gaze out over Put-in-Bay Harbor, take in the sight of Perry’s Monument, and on clear days, even catch a glimpse of Cleveland in the distance.

For a taste of the island’s freshest perch tacos, Hooligans on Catawba Ave is the place to be. Across from Derivera Park, Mossbacks is another must-visit for Lake Erie Perch fans, while those with a taste for Alaskan King Crab will find their cravings satisfied when it’s in season. Each restaurant on Put-in-Bay adds its own flavor to the island’s culinary scene, ensuring every meal is an adventure in itself.


Put-in-Bay Restaurants for Breakfast, Lunch, and Dinner

For breakfast at Put-in-Bay, try Eggs Benedict at Frosty Bar, Bloody Mary’s at Reel Bar, omelets at Pasquale’s Cafe, or crepes at the Forge. Grab pastries and coffee at the Village Bakery or enjoy margaritas with live entertainment nearby. Dairy Isle offers ice cream anytime as well.

Wanting Lunch downtown? Enjoy a burger at the Boathouse Bar, a Cuban sandwich at Topsy Turvey, or street vendor hot dogs. For late-night cravings, order Cameo pizza from Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grille. Want pizza delivered? Call 419-285-4444 for free late-night delivery from Cameo in Put-in-Bay.

You’ll also find gourmet sandwiches, pizza, and Caribbean conch fritters by the water, along with many cafés for light meals and coffee. Check out the Put-in-Bay Brewery for local brews and the distillery with outdoor seating.
For diverse dining options, visit Hooligans for burgers, the Old Forge for crepes, Fire Engine Pizza Company for pizza, the Keys for the best Cuban sandwich, and Rita’s Cantina for loaded nachos and margaritas.

After Hours at Put-in-Bay

After a day of delicious meals, get ready for Put-in-Bay’s exciting nightlife! As the sun sets, the island’s bars and restaurants come alive with music, laughter, and beautiful views. Downtown is the heart of the action, where you can mingle with locals and enjoy the island’s cool atmosphere.

For live music and stunning sunsets, try the Keys or Boardwalk restaurant. Delaware Avenue is the place to be for popular bars like Mr. Eds and the Roundhouse Bar. For a quieter spot, Joe’s Bar near the state park is a local favorite, just a short golf cart ride away. Beer fanatics will love Biergarten, and the Reel Bar is great for live entertainment too. For the best mojitos, head to Mojito Bay.

Want a bigger party? Our nightclubs are perfect or try a Rolling Pub Tour to pedal around the island. Put-in-Bay’s nightlife is safe and fun, just a quick golf cart or taxi ride from your lodging place. Stay overnight to make the most of it. Come and experience the Key West of the Midwest!


Frequently asked Questions

Can you walk around Put-in-Bay with alcohol?

At South Bass Island (Put-in-Bay), open containers of alcohol are not permitted on the streets, in golf carts, or outside of bars. But don’t worry, you can still enjoy drinks at the many restaurants with outdoor seating. Savor tasty meals with your favorite beverages at places like the Boardwalk, Upper Deck, and Rita’s Cantina on Bayview Ave. For a scenic setting, head to The Keys near Jet Express. If you’re looking for lively evening entertainment, Delaware Ave. in downtown Put-in-Bay is the spot featuring Mr. Ed’s Bar & Grille and Cameo Pizza. Experience the island’s vibrant dining atmosphere while respecting local regulations.

How long is the ferry ride at Put-in-Bay?

Getting to Put-in-Bay is a breeze, whether you take the 18-minute Miller Ferry from Catawba Island or the Jet Express from Port Clinton (25 minutes) or Sandusky (45 minutes). On the Miller Ferry, relax and enjoy the Lake Erie waters, catching views of Perry’s Monument and nearby islands. Don’t miss trying the tasty nachos and burritos at Taco Bay once you’re there.

The Jet Express offers its own delightful ride, sometimes providing glimpses of Cleveland. Arriving in the heart of Put-in-Bay, you’re steps away from excellent dining options like The Keys, Upper Deck on the Boardwalk, Hooligans, and the Boathouse Bar. Plus, downtown’s bustling nightlife awaits at Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grille, Mossbacks, Frosty Bar, and the Reel Bar. Whichever route you choose, a quick trip to Put-in-Bay opens the door to a world of great memories.


Are there cars on Put-in-Bay?

In Put-in-Bay, Ohio, while cars are allowed, they’re not the most popular way to get around. Golf carts are the go-to choice for exploring South Bass Island. Their small size and easy maneuverability make them perfect for navigating the quaint and often busy streets of downtown Put-in-Bay, especially around Derivera Park’s cluster of restaurants.
You’ll find plenty of golf cart rental options near both the Miller Ferry and Jet Express docks and scattered around the island. Considering the short 1.7-mile stretch from the state park to Perry’s Monument, the compact nature of the island makes golf carts even more appealing. By choosing a golf cart, you’re set for a smooth and enjoyable journey on Put-In-Bay.

What street are bars on in Put-in-Bay?

Discover Downtown Put-in-Bay’s Bar Scene on Delaware Ave.

In Put-in-Bay, the center of the bar scene is on Delaware Ave in downtown Put-In-Bay. While there are a few bars scattered outside downtown South Bass Island, the main hub of nightlife activity is around Derivera Park. This area is home to several popular spots like Fishbowl, Frosty’s Bar, and Mr. Ed’s Bar & Grille. The great thing about these downtown bars is their proximity to one another. Visitors can easily walk from one place to another, making it simple to experience the varied and lively bar scene that Put-in-Bay offers.

Do you have to be 21 to enter bars in Put-in-Bay?

In Put-in-Bay, many bars downtown welcome underage guests until a certain time, after which they switch to a strict 21+ policy. You also need you’re physical ID, they will not take paper IDs, or pictures/screenshots of an ID.

South Bass Island, especially during peak season and on weekends, is a popular destination for adults. While the island is family-friendly by day, its nightlife caters more to an adult crowd. Nonetheless, families visiting Put-in-Bay, Ohio, have plenty of great options, including eateries that offer delightful meals. A known spot is The Boardwalk, which has outdoor seating and breathtaking views of Lake Erie, ensuring a dining experience that’s enjoyable for all ages.