Put-in-Bay Hotel Choices

Seeking Put-in-Bay hotels and resorts can be a bit of an adventure for a first time visitor. Because we only have guests a few months of the year, large hotel chains do not operate on the island. What you’ll find instead is locally owned small businesses, who take the time to make vacations special for their guests.

Many of the downtown hotels have amenities like pool bars and golf cart rentals. Put-in-Bay resorts outside of downtown work to cater to guests who don’t want to be in the hustle and bustle for their entire stay. Whatever it is that you’re looking for in your Put-in-Bay lodging, we’re confident you’ll find it here!

Put-in-Bay Island Club Rentals

Island Club Put in Bay pool

Island Club Rentals

Put-in-Bay Island Club Rentals is the preferred rental home company for Put-in-Bay Ohio. MAKE A RESERVATION! Visitors come to our vacation rentals every summer and enjoy the island life that is the hallmark of South Bass Island. You won’t believe you are in Ohio and may have visions of sitting in Key West, FL. Enjoy all the comforts of home while you experience everything that Put-in-Bay has to offer. CHECK ONLINE AVAILABILITY! Or call us at 216-898-9951 for a personalized experience with one of our specially-trained reservation agents. Check-in instructions will be provided upon booking

The Island Club Rentals feature 73 three and four bedroom homes in a private community. A pool is centrally located in the development and is perfect for the kids. All of the vacation homes are fully furnished with central air conditioning, a full kitchen, two baths, a private deck or patio with propane grills to BBQ, new high speed WiFi and much more. If you’re visiting Put-in-Bay with a group of friends or family, this is the place for you. read more

Quick Info:
1490 Put-In-Bay Road, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456, United States

The Commodore Resort in Downtown Put-in-Bay

mist pool swim-up bar put-in-bay

Commodore Resort

The new Commodore Resort Hotel on Put-in-Bay is an updated version of one of the island’s original party spots. CHECK AVAILABILITY! We feature rooms which include: king jacuzzi suites, eight-person suites, and the traditional two double bed standard rooms. In addition, handicapped rooms are available.

Everyone loves the new rooms, the new amenities, and the new superior service that we offer. All of the rooms in the new building come equipped with high-speed internet, microwaves, refrigerators, and the majority of the rooms have a view overlooking the infamous MIST pool area and tiki bar. We have catering available for larger groups of up to 100 people for business meetings, banquets, weddings, and parties. Guests can opt to rent upstairs in The Green Room, Put-in-Bay’s newest dance club, or rent our the whole Mr. Ed’s Bar & Grill for a private function. If you are looking for an indoor/outdoor venue for your party or wedding, we also offer our MIST tiki bar area which can accommodate up to 200 people. read more

Quick Info:
272 Delaware Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456, United States

Brand New Put-in-Bay Waterfront Condos

Put in Bay Waterfront Condos

Put-in-Bay Waterfront Condos

The Put-in-Bay Waterfront Condos are the premier lakefront Put-in-Bay lodging choice for your Lake Erie island getaway. CHECK AVAILABILITY! We are close to home in body but also far away in spirit.

How often can you plan a party weekend with your friends or a small vacation with your family on an island surrounded by water? There are no other rentals on Put-in-Bay with such an impressive and expansive view of the lake and surrounding islands.

As a result, you can relax out on your private lake view back deck. This lovely unit resides on some of the most prime Lake Erie real estate and is next to the airport. read more

Quick Info:
1240 Tri-Motor Drive, Put-in-Bay, OH, 43456

Victory Station Hotel in Put-in-Bay

victory station put in bay

Victory Station Hotel

The Victory Station Hotel on Put-in-Bay, is located in the very heart of downtown. CHECK AVAILABILITY! Built in 2013, the Victory Station is the newest and most modern hotel offering on the island, but still displaying the old world charm. Furthermore, the lodging maintains the Victorian feel of the island and is not a “party” hotel.

Victory Station Hotel Charm

Guests will be taken back to Put-in-Bay’s early days. When stepping into your hotel room, the ambiance is remarkable. Moreover, all of the modern conveniences of home are available including a flat-screen TV for catching the news or the big game.  The location is ideal, a short stroll from the Jet Express Put in Bay Ferry Dock. read more

Quick Info:
489 Catawba Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456, United States

Put-in-Bay Poolview Condos

poolview condos

Put-in-Bay Poolview Condos

The Put-in-Bay Poolview Condos have the cozy lodging and ideal location for your group. CHECK AVAILABILITY! This property is adjacent to the Put-in-Bay Waterfront Condos. The highlight of this property is the fact that is located right on the lakeshore of Lake Erie. So, stay near the lake while on the island. Seems like a smart choice!

There are eight poolview condos available. Each Put-in-Bay Poolview Condo has new high speed internet, 2 bedrooms, 2 baths, and an eat-in kitchen. The kitchen is stocked with the necessities to make and serve a meal, just bring your own ood. Also, each unit sleeps up to eight guests comfortably in 4 beds total in 2 bedrooms. read more

Quick Info:
1240 Tri Motor Drive, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456, United States

Bird’s Nest Resort

Put in Bay Resort

Make your next Put-in-Bay, Ohio getaway the best yet with unique accommodations from Birds Nest Resort, boasting a selection of options near the shores of Lake Erie, from budget-conscious King, Double or Efficiency Double  hotel-style rooms for couples and small families to spacious 2 and 3 bedroom cottage rentals for larger groups. Spanning 9 tranquil acres on South Bass Island, Birds Nest Resort offers a great location and amenities that the whole family can appreciate, including private spaces, a resort swimming pool, and scenic nature trails. Conveniently situated across the street from the airport, Birds Nest Resort is just moments from Put-in-Bay’s downtown area, and a mile from Miller Ferry. Families will love Perry’s Cave Family Fun Center, an amusement complex for all ages, less than one mile away. Guests can reach Joe’s Bar and the island’s many attractions with ease by golf cart, too! read more

Quick Info:
1371 Langram Road

Put-in-Bay Hotels

A shot of the Commodore Resort and MIST Pool Bar, during calm hours.

In your search for lodging at Put-in-Bay, you’ve likely come across all sorts of different places to stay. From resorts, to Waterfront Condos looking right at Lake Erie, to Put-in-Bay VRBO options in a great location, you might feel overwhelmed. These are all great options, but you might just be seeking something a little more familiar. What you are likely most familiar with, in that case, is the hotel, and Put-in-Bay has no shortage of them.

These hotels range from sprawling downtown Put-in-Bay hotspots right in the heart of the action to boutique hotels off the beaten path. A place like the Commodore Resort or the Edgewater Hotel are right in the thick of everything, and the Victory Station Hotel and Bay Lodging Resort are just detached enough from the downtown scene to be peaceful, while still being in touching distance to enjoy Put-in-Bay’s famous nightlife (our favorite spot is Mr. Ed’s!)

Put-in-Bay Room With a Poolview!

Most of these hotels also grant you access to one or more of Put-in-Bay’s famous pool bars. That’s great news because visiting a swim-up bar is one of the absolute must-do’s of Put-in-Bay bars.

This isn’t something you can find anywhere else in this area of the country but Put-in-Bay. Swim-up bars are typically the territory of Caribbean resorts. Then again, that’s the vibe you’ll find at Put-in-Bay as a whole. If you are there on a day with good weather, you’d be forgiven for mistaking it for Key West.

Alternative Put-in-Bay Ohio Lodging Options

From the shadow of Perry’s Monument to off the beaten path, there are vacation rentals all over the island. Spend your getaway at the Put-in-Bay Condos or Island Club Rentals and get your entire group together under the same roof. Check in is as simple as punching a code into the door! The condos have an incredible lakeview and both have their own private swimming pool and free wifi. These rental homes are often within walking distance of many attractions like Perry’s Cave, and a short taxi ride from the rest. Take a quick ferry ride from Catawba Island in Port Clinton, a stones throw away from Cedar Point in Sandusky, and enjoy a family getaway at the Bay. Experience the Lake Erie Islands as they were meant to be seen, as one of the premier vacation spots, not just for people from Cleveland or Toledo, but anywhere in the United States!

Put-in-Bay Hotel Amenities

Many of the best hotels also offer amenities like golf cart and moped rentals onsite to help you get around the island with ease. You can park your cart right out front! Of course if you’re only coming to the island for the nightlife, from some of these hotels all you’ll need to get around is your feet. And if that isn’t the case at your particular hotel, there are Put-in-Bay taxis all around the island to get you where you need to go, often as cheap as $3 a person!

Your Source for Put-in-Bay Lodging

We hope you find this Put-in-Bay hotels and resorts information helpful. We want to match every guest on our island to their perfect lodging option. Because there are too many things to do on South Bass Island to only take a day trip. You need to come enjoy a couple summer nights at the Bay, aka the Key West of the Midwest!

Put-in-Bay Cabins

When you come stay at Put-in-Bay, you generally have two styles of lodging you can choose from: Hotels/resorts, or cabins. Cabins offer a lot more privacy and whether that means more peace and quiet or less, you can choose which you prefer. With companies such as the Island Club to rent a cabin from you should have absolutely no problem finding a place best suited for you.

Put-in-Bay cabins are also great if you’re staying with a group of friends because more of you can stay together at once, and you can also rent cabins next to each other and have a really great time hanging out between the two. Also, just because you’re getting a cabin doesn’t necessarily mean it’s in the woods! Lots of great options can be found in town as well! You can also find stand-alone or grouped cabins just the same.

VRBO Put-in-Bay

VRBO is a great agency to book through, however you must understand we highly recommend booking directly with owners as you will pay anywhere from 8-10% extra in hidden fees through their website or app. If you still plan on using them simply search “VRBO Put-in-Bay” and all available listings should pop right up! It’s possible that some hotels may come up as well so if you’re looking for a cabin make sure that’s what it really is.

Once on their website, you choose your location and a calendar will pop up where you can enter the dates you desire to book. Once you’ve entered this information all of the available listings will pop up and you can browse around until you find one that seems right for you! Choose one that looks appealing and read below for extra information on the owner and how you can book.

Frequently Asked  Put-in-Bay Hotel Questions

Where can I find Put-in-Bay hotel information?

Aside from the listings above, we recommend consulting putinbay.com, which has up-to-date information and detailed listings for all of Put-in-Bay’s best hotels. You will also find information on attractions, upcoming events and more!

What Put-in-Bay hotels have a 1-night stay?

While hotels policies can change from year to year, at present, we are unaware of any hotels that allow one night stays. Island Club and Put-in-Bay Condos are alternative lodging options that offer single night reservation in select parts of the season. Contact them directly for more information at 216-898-9951.

What are the best Hotels with a pool at Put-in-Bay?

We recommend the Commodore Resort in downtown Put-in-Bay, as it is home to MIST Pool Bar, Put-in-Bay’s most famous swim-up bar. Put-in-Bay is known for its swim-up bars, as this is pretty much the only place in the northern United States to find them. A swim-up bar should definitely be on your Put-in-Bay checklist, and MIST is the best of the bunch!

Which hotels on Put-in-Bay are pet-friendly?

None as far as we know of. The only place on the island that we know of that permits pets is the Island Club, which allows them for stays from Sunday-Thursday.

How can I get to my hotel from the ferry?

If you ride the Miller Ferry, when you disembark, follow the crowd up the hill, where you will find a row of bubble-top taxi vans ready to take you anywhere on the island. If you come to Put-in-Bay via the Jet Express, taxis will frequently pass the downtown dock. At neither location should you expect to wait more than a minute or two for a ride regardless of time of day.

Other Put-in-Bay Hotels

Park Hotel

The Park Hotel is centrally located on the busy downtown Put-in-Bay strip where all the fun bars and restaurants can be found. As you walk out the front door, you are just steps away from DeRivera Park and the marina. The Park Hotel was built in the 1870s making a historical building. The Victorian Era is showcased in the hotel’s interior. You’ll even stumble across the only speak easy on Put-in-Bay. The Red Moon Bar dates back to the days of prohibition when bootleggers used the Lake Erie waters to smuggle their alcohol. In all, the Park Hotel is small, yet fun hotel choice on Put-in-Bay!

Islander Inn

Looking for a Caribbean-themed getaway without actually making your way to the Cayman Islands? The Islander Inn on Put-in-Bay Island has what you might be searching for. Guests enjoy sitting poolside at one the two swim-up bars onsite. The resort has four outdoor pools, 100 recently remodeled rooms, and golf cart rentals onsite exclusively for resort guests. Here, people can enjoy nearby family fun activities like Adventure Bay,  the island’s only arcade. Weekend warriors enjoy more adult-friendly attractions that are located just a short walk away from the hotel. These attractions include, MIST Swim-up Bar, SPLASH Swim-up Bar and all the other fun downtown bars on Delaware Ave.

Bay Shore Resort

The Bay Shore Resort is located a short walk away from the iconic Perry’s Victory and International Peace Memorial. This lakefront property features waterfront views with balconies. From a waterfront balcony, guests can bird watch and enjoy views of other surrounding Lake Erie Islands. There is a tiki bar and restaurant on the premises as well. Lastly, guests have the chance to go for a swim in their heated outdoor swimming pool.

Grand Islander Hotel

The Grand Islander Hotel is another centrally located Put-in-Bay hotel.  Guests staying at the Grand Islander are close to all the action. Right across the street you have Hooligans, The Put-in-Bay Brewery, Reel Bar and much more. If those aren’t enough restaurant and bar options, guests can take advantage of free access to SPLASH swim up bar.  The hotel recently renovated over 50 rooms and is reasonably priced compared to other Put-in-Bay Hotels.

Edgewater Hotel

Edgewater Hotel / Motel is located on Delaware Avenue. Here, guests can walk over to another Put-in-Bay hotel and have free continental breakfast. There are plenty of golf cart rentals onsite. If they are out of carts, you’ll be just a two-minute walk away from the Put-in-Bay Golf Cart Depot.

Put-in-Bay Resort & Conference Center

The Put-in-Bay Resort & Conference Center is home of the Blue Marlin Swim-up bar.  The hotel features a large jacuzzi that is attached to the swim up bar.  There is a small conference room available for business meetings, weddings and other gatherings requiring a large space. The hotel rooms come in different sizes depending on how large your group might be and there is free breakfast every morning in the lobby. In addition, this hotel is roughly a 10-minute walk from Mr. Ed’s Bar and all the other downtown action.

Bay Lodging Resort

Bay lodging resort is about a 15-minute walk from downtown Put-in-Bay. It is home of the Buckeye Tiki Bar and has golf cart rentals onsite. The closest restaurant would be the Goat Soup & Whiskey which has one of the best menus on the island.

Miscellaneous Put-in-Bay Island Info

Resort hotels, luxury suites, and rental homes are some of the things you can come to expect when you stay for your bay vacation. You can click our lodging tab to check availability on all hotels, resorts, and guest rooms available for rent. Bicycle rentals and golf cart rentals can be found all over the island.

put-in-bay, oh 43456