There are so many things to do in Put-in-Bay! From fast casual to dine-in, to Put-in-Bay bars and pubs to breakfast diners, and everything in-between, the only problem with Put-in-Bay restaurants is that there are too many great ones to choose from! South Bass Island has something for everyone’s taste buds! So head over on a Put-in-Bay ferry today!

Swipe Right Pizza

Swipe Right Pizza

Swipe Right Pizza – Put-in-Bay, Ohio

Swipe Right Pizza is the island’s newest option to feed a hungry tummy. They do it with some awesome pizza that’s both hot & fresh. The best part? They do it for less than the big guys on Put-in-Bay, Ohio!

Each one of these delicious pizzas features legalized marinara sauce! You heard that right. It even says so on their pizza menu on their website!

The whimsical menu is fun to peruse and it is full of little surprises if you look hard enough. Swipe Right features signature pizzas such as the Lorena Bobbitt (featuring: mushrooms, onions, and banana pepper). The Lorena Bobbitt pizza is meatless, of course, so don’t ask for any. read more

Quick Info:
1402 Catawba Avenue, Put-in-Bay, OH, USA
419-742-9222

Mr. Ed’s Bar & Grille

mr eds bar and grille

Mr Ed’s Bar and Grille is a crowd favorite at Put-in-Bay.  This famous Put-in-Bay hotspot is not only one of the best places to grab a drink, it’s also the new home of Cameo Pizza. Cameo offers their specialty pizzas, chicken wings and more out of Mr. Ed’s kitchen. Diners can eat inside the bar, or opt for lunch on the outdoor patio.  So, at Mr Ed’s Bar and Grille there are options for everybody.  

The location of Mr. Ed’s is ideal, on the main street of Put-in-Bay.  Furthermore, the Delaware Avenue block has the majority of the shops, restaurants and attractions on the island.  Moreover, there are several different areas to enjoy at Mr. Ed’s.  First, the main floor bar features live entertainment nightly.  Here, guests can grab an incredible pizza and cold drink and enjoy some of the best entertainment on Put-in-Bay.  read more

Quick Info:
272 Delaware Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456, United States
419-285-3101

Subway

subway

Subway is the place to eat fresh on Put-in-Bay.  The location is in the lobby of the Commodore Resort.  The smells of freshly baked bread lure in customers.  Additionally, the variety of selections and value make this a visitor favorite.  Therefore, to save some funds during a Put-in-Bay visit, Subway is a viable option.

The Commodore Resort is situated just behind Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grille.  So, to find this sandwich shop from Delaware Ave., just look for the Subway sign in front of Mr. Ed’s.  Then, walk right down the alley for a sub made to order.  The choices are aplenty.  Opt for a Subway Club piled high with roast beef, turkey and ham.  Instead, go for the savory meatball sub, complete with hearty meatballs and marinara.  All subs can be personalized with a large selection of fresh vegetables and sauces. read more

Quick Info:
272 Delaware Ave, Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456, United States
419-285-5555

Cameo Pizza

cameo pizza

Cameo Pizza of Put-in-Bay prides themselves on using fresh ingredients. The crust and sauce is fresh, made daily.   So, diners can expect a fresh and tasty pizza every time.  Additionally, Cameo’s offers subs, wraps, salads and more.  There is a reason this has become a staple of Put-in-Bay.

The location of this favored eatery is in downtown Put-in-Bay on Catawba Avenue.  Put-in-Bay Town Hall, the Put-in-Bay Police Department and the Lake Erie Islands Historical Museum are just steps away.  Guests can opt to visit this location for carry out service.  Otherwise, delivery service is available.  Delivery hours plunge deep into the night during peak season, so there is always time to enjoy a Cameo pizza.  Late night service is available up to as late as 4 AM at the busiest of times. read more

Quick Info:
438 Catawba Avenue, Put-in-Bay, OH, United States
419-285-4444

Boathouse Restaurant

boathouse bar

The Boathouse Bar and Grill on Put-in-Bay is ready to serve you.  They have been offering delectable meals and cold drinks for over 50 years.  Additionally, the Boathouse is the proud home of outstanding island entertainment.  Great eats and great bands is their motto and they certainly live up to it.

The location is nothing short of prime.  Located in downtown Put-in-Bay on Hartford Avenue, the Boathouse is near all of the action.  Also, the Jet Express dock and downtown marina is just a short walk away.  So, this is a favorite among boaters due to the proximity to the water.  DeRivera Park is just across the street, as is Kimberly’s Carousel.  So, finding this island favorite is a breeze.  Bring your Put-In-Bay Golf Cart Rental and park it along Delaware Ave, in the heart of it all. read more

Quick Info:
218 Hartford Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH, United States
419-285-5665

Chicken Patio

chicken-patio

The Chicken Patio is nothing short of an island institution.  Founded in 1952, generations of Put-in-Bay guests have enjoyed their fare.  Most notably, the feature item is open pit chicken basted in a house made wine sauce.  Originally, just a small grill covered the cooking needs.  Today, a 21 foot charcoal grill accommodates the huge demand.

World Famous Roundhouse Bar

Location is everything.  Moreover, the Chicken Patio is no exception to this rule of thumb.  The World Famous Roundhouse Bar is directly next door.  Additionally, the historic Park Hotel is just behind the grill.  Initially, The Roundhouse Bar was opened in 1863 as the Columbia Restaurant.  Here, guests could choose from beer, wine, snacks and food.  Most notably, at the time cottage cheese and ice cream were big sellers. read more

Quick Info:
60 Delaware Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456, United States
419-285-3581

Fish Shack

Put in Bay fish shak

The Boardwalk Restaurant complex is home to the Fish Shack.  Here, diners can try some local fare.  Most notably, the Lake Erie Walleye and Yellow Perch are exceptional.  Fortunately, for those who do not care for seafood, other eateries reside within the building.  These stands feature hamburgers, chicken tenders and more.

Fish Shack Location and Island Views

The Boardwalk Restaurant is a pillar of the dining options on the island of Put in Bay.  A waterfront location affords guests panoramic views of Lake Erie.  Also, the neighboring islands of Gibraltar and Middle Bass Island can are visible from the outdoor terraces.

The Ohio State University owns Gibraltar Island. Moreover, they have been conducting fresh water research here for over 100 years.  Additionally, the islands history is rich with prominent guests visiting the island. Jay Cooke, a civil war financier, once owned the island.  Several US Presidents and other dignitaries spent time on Gibraltar Island.  Also, Cooke ordered the construction of what became known as Cooke Castle.  From the Fish Shack diners can view this spectacular structure.  In 1865 the project completed. Today, OSU is working on restoring the building to its original splendor. read more

Quick Info:
341 Bayview Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH, United States
419-285-3695

The Goat Soup & Whiskey

The Goat Soup and Whiskey Dining

The Goat Soup & Whiskey on Put-in-Bay is a choice eatery and pub.  Priding themselves on fresh and local ingredients, this is a must visit location.  The scratch made soups and carefully crafted cocktails are just a portion of the fabulous offerings. So, stop in and see what the buzz is about.

Goat Soup and Whiskey Location

The Goat is on Catawba Road between Mother of Sorrows Catholic Church and Heineman’s Winery.  This location is less than one half mile to downtown Put-in-Bay.  Also, surrounding this property is the beautiful Coopers Woods. Coopers Woods is a tract of wooded land that has remained natural for generations.  Lovely walking trails grace the space.  Wildflowers and wildlife alike are teeming here. read more

Quick Info:
820 Catawba Ave, Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456, United States
419-285-4628

Hooligans

hooligans irish pub

Hooligans Irish Pub is a lively eatery on the magical isle of Put-in-Bay.  Here, patrons can get the taste and feel of “The Emerald Isle. The Irish hospitality is worthy of a visit. Most importantly, the staff strives to provide an excellent dining experience.  Stop in for a pint.

Hooligans Location

The location of Hooligans is on Catawba Ave.  Furthermore, the Put-in-Bay Town Hall and Put-in-Bay Police Department are directly next door.  So, from this location guests are close to the action.

Inside, the interior is beautiful. Impressive wood working is found throughout.  The rich woods and Irish themed decor set the mood for a memorable experience.  There are multiple seating areas available.  Moreover, diners can choose the main dining room for table side service.  Otherwise, guests can opt to sit at the bar.  Lastly,  the lovely outside patio is a great option. From this vista, guests will have a front seat to the action. Catawba Avenue is oftentimes very busy, with golf carts whizzing by.  People watching at its finest. read more

Quick Info:
421 Catawba Avenue, Put-in-Bay, OH, United States
419-285-8000

The Keys

the keys put in bay

The Keys Restaurant brings Florida to Put-in-Bay.  Key West is well represented at this waterfront restaurant.  So, slow down and enjoy the island breezes.

A waterfront location makes the Keys an excellent choice.  Located in downtown Put-in-Bay next to the Jet Express Put in Bay dock, it is easy to find. Also, Perry’s Victory and International Peace Memorial is within view.  Moreover, this monument relates to the Battle of Lake Erie.  Oliver Hazard Perry was victorious, protecting the island from invasion.  Additionally, the monument serves as a testament to the ever lasting peace between the countries. read more

Quick Info:
227 Bayview Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH, United States
419-285-5397