What is the history of the Lake Erie Islands?

Located in North America in the shallow western end of perch-rich Lake Erie is a group of 20 or more islands just north of and part of the State of Ohio rich with Put-in-Bay history. One of these, South Bass Island (also called Put-in-Bay for the main village on the island), served as a base of operations for Admiral Oliver Hazard Perry. It was from the harbor called Put-in-Bay that Adm. Perry sailed to defeat the British fleet under Robert H. Barclay during the war of 1812. The American victory in the battle of Lake Erie gave the country and the United States Navy a memorable slogan of positive accomplishments: “We have met the enemy and they are ours…”

Oliver Hazard Perry

Today there stands at Put-in-Bay a beautiful Greek Doric column, the Perry’s Victory and International Peace Memorial (aka “The Monument”) with associated Visitors’ Center. This 352-foot granite shaft commemorates not only a naval battle but a peace between England, Canada, and the United States that has lasted for more than 150 years. The 3,987 mile boundary between the United States and Canada is the longest unguarded international frontier in the world.

The brigs, ships, and sloops with their long guns and carronades are gone. Their place has been taken by yachts, motorboats, and sailboats. Many captains of these pleasure craft plot a course for Put-in-Bay seeking relaxation from the tensions of the city. Others — yachtless landlubbers — board a Put-in-Bay ferry or airplane for their trip to an island in Ohio’s Lake Erie vacationland.

ferry steam ship

Urban and rural tourists have been coming the Put-in-Bay for over 100 years by steamship, jet boats, small aircraft, and occasionally small cars over the ice in the winter months. From the top of the Monument, visitors can observe the site of the Battle of Lake Erie and on a clear day see both Canada and the USA. Guests can also probe the depths of Perry’s Cave, bicycle around the island, or sip locally produced wine or grape juice. The island is rich with Put-in-Bay history.

Early Ohio Island Explorers

Put-in-Bay history tells us that he earliest visitors were the American Indians. Many Indian arrowheads, stone axes, and other implements of blue and white flints were turned up during construction. Indians visited Put-in-Bay when ice conditions allowed the crossing to hunt raccoons and other animals. They also followed the deer herds to and from the islands when iced over.

Historical Actors

The French explorer and fur trader Louis Jolliet was the first white man to travel on the lake. An unidentified group of explorers sailed among the Bass Islands in July of 1784. They made charts of the islands, naming one of them Pudding Bay because the shape of the harbor resembled a pudding bag. Other log books referred to the harbor as Puden Bay. The Lake Erie Islands were included in the tract of land claimed by the Connecticut Land Company and which is known as the Western Reserve. The earliest white inhabitants known to have occupied the Islands were the French.

Seth Done brought a number of laborers who cleared over 100 acres of land and planted wheat in the summer and fall of 1811. He also imported 400 sheep and 150 hogs to graze on the acorn and hickory nuts which were abundant on the island. The first effort to settle on Put-in-Bay ended with the coming of the war of 1812. The workers were busy threshing grain when British soldiers drove them off in the Fall of 1812 and destroyed the remainder of their crop.


The War of 1812

Western Lake Erie and the surrounding land areas on Ohio, Michigan and Canadian Ontario were the scenes of skirmishes and battles during the War of 1812. None so famous as that fought by Commander Oliver Hazard Perry. The American cause suffered a series of humiliating defeats at the outset of the struggle. General William Hull’s invasion of Canada failed, and Hull, in disgrace, surrendered Detroit to the British in August 1812. The force under General James Winchester was annihilated at the River Raisin (Monroe, Michigan), in January 1813.

Lake Erie Indians

British and Indian invasions of Ohio at Fort Meigs (Perrysburg) and at Fort Stephenson (Fremont) were repulsed in May and August. The turning point of the war in The Old Northwest came with Oliver Hazard Perry’s victory over the British fleet in the Battle of Lake Erie, 10 September 1813. The naval victory made it possible for General William Henry Harrison to invade Canada and defeat the British and Indians at the River Thames in October 1813. A true piece of Put-in-Bay history!

Put-in-Bay Harbor was used by Perry as a base of operations. From the Bass Islands he could quickly sail to Sandusky Bay for conferences with Harrison or scout the British forces at Fort Malden (Amherstburg, Ontario), in the Detroit River. When the men and ships were not so engaged, there were training duties such as preparing the ships for actions and gunnery practice. The American fleet had sailed from Erie, Pennsylvania, on 12 August 1813 and arrived off Sandusky Bay on the sixteenth. Perry conferred with Generals Harrison and Lewis Cass regarding the next step to take in prosecuting the campaign.

The British fleet under Captain Robert H. Barclay was sighted by a lookout in the masthead of Perry’s flagship, the brig Lawrence, at 5:00 a.m., Friday, 10 September 1813. The Battle of Lake Erie began at 11:45 a.m. and ended a few minutes after 3:00 p.m. British supremacy on the lake came to an end with the capture of the entire enemy fleet of six vessels.

Three Country Flags

The conflict began eight miles northwest of Put-in-Bay and reached its climax at West Sister Island fourteen miles away. The triumphant American captain dashed off a short note on the back of an old letter to William Henry Harrison:

U.S. Brig Niagara, off Western Sister Island head of Lake Erie, Sept. 10, 1813, 4 p.m.


Dear General —
We have met the enemy and they are ours, two ships, two brigs, one schooner and one sloop.
Yours with great respect and esteem, O.H. Perry

Island Life After the War

After the War of 1812, Aschell (Shell) Johnson lived on Put-in-Bay for three years. The next settlers were Henry and Sally Hyde who came in 1818. The Hydes brought 500 head of sheep to the island. A.P. Edwards then began to develop Put-in-Bay bringing in laborers to erect the necessary buildings. John Pierpoint built a dock in the harbor and another one known as the West Dock and the rest is Put-in-Bay history.

The first permanent settler to come to Put-in-Bay was Philip Vroman in 1843. He settled on the island and remained on the island until his death 68 years later. In 1845 Gibraltar Island in the harbor was occupied by a group of government surveyors and engineers who were engaged in making charts of the lake. They found it necessary to cut a strip 45 feet wide running through the woods of Put-in-Bay so they could site the instruments properly. The strip was used as a road by the islanders called “Sight Road”. Today it is referred to as the airport road, but officially it is named Langram Road.

Lake Erie Islands

In 1854 a Spanish merchant name Joseph DeRivera bought South Bass, Middle Bass, Sugar, Gibraltar, Ballast and Starve Islands for a price of $44,000. He began to develop the islands building a saw mill and a starve mill in the fall of 1854. He had the county engineer survey the area in 10-acre lots. In the first ten years, DeRivera sold 42 parcels of land in South and Middle Bass Island. He sold a quarter acre of land to the South Bass Board of Education for a dollar. The big park in downtown Put-in-Bay is named DeRivera Park in his honor, and a trust is responsible for the park and other land still today. The grape-growing and wine-making industry began in the Lake Erie Island in the 1850s, and Put-in-Bay’s attraction as a historical island resort was just being developed.

Large celebrations were held in 1852, 1858, and 1859 honoring Oliver Hazard Perry’s victory over the British in 1813. Put-in-Bay was becoming known for its delicious grapes and excellent Lake Erie Islands wines and as a place where the vacationist, via the steamboat, could “get away from it all” for a few hours. The population grew as farmers came to the island to plant vineyards and as others became involved in the resort business. About 500 persons were permanent residents of Put-in-Bay by the early 1860s.

Put-in-Bay Becomes a Commercial Township

In 1866 a story in the Sandusky Daily Commercial Register told of the growth of Put-in-Bay township. Islanders owned 103 horses, 165 cattle, 206 hogs and one mule. The fields were planted in wheat, oats, buckwheat, rye, barley, potatoes, sorghum, tobacco, hay and clover. The vineyards were a main source of income. 72 acres of vines had been planted in 1865 to bring the total to 422. Grape production for 1865 totaled 1,117,801 pounds and 33,805 gallons of wine were pressed. The future looked bright for island farmers.

Local island government was now desired and to this end, John Stone, Simon Fox and others from the three Bass Islands petitioned the Ottawa County commissioners for permission to organize Put-in-Bay Township. On June 22, 1861, the electors selected their town trustees. In May of 1876, 15 years later, after the three islands were organized as a township, a portion of South Bass was incorporated as a village which most people now refer to as downtown Put-in-Bay, Ohio.

st pauls episcopal church

St. Paul’s Episcopal Church was built in 1865 on land purchased by Jay Cooke from Jose DeRivera for $10.00 (the land for the school was sold for $1.00). The deed to the land stipulated it was for the construction of an Episcopal church. Islanders raised the initial funds to build a church and were financially assisted by Jay Cooke. Jay Cooke’s heirs gave the land to the Episcopal church in the early 1900s. Mother of Sorrows Roman Catholic Church was established in 1866.

The Put-in-Bay Telegraph Company was incorporated in 1873, with a two and seven-eighth mile cable between Catawba Point and South Bass Island. In the 1930s, dial phones replaced old hand-cranked wall instruments. In May of 1906, another moment of Put-in-Bay history occurred when the street lighting system was converted to electricity.

Put-in-Bay History of Tourism

In its heyday, around the 1850s to the 1900s, several steamships, some holding up to 1,500 passengers, serviced the island on a regular basis. Tourists were treated to a variety of hotels, including the 300 x 600 foot Put n Bay Hotel Victory with 625 guest rooms. At that time, it was one of the largest hotels in America also featuring the first coed swimming pool. Elaborate ceremonies were planned for the laying of the cornerstone of The Victory. Seven steamboats brought 8,000 people to the island. The Beebe house with a wide hall running 500 feet through the center had a dining room that could seat nearly a thousand diners. The hotel could house over 800 persons.

Hotel Victory

The Hotel Victory Hotel is gone, destroyed by fire in 1919, but it’s remains can still be viewed at the state park. The area comprising South Bass Island State Park was added to the state park system in the early 1950s. Putin Bay has been a summer resort town for more than 100 years with a rich tourist trade and strong Put-in-Bay history.

Today the island is a vibrant tourist resort complete with plenty of Put-in-Bay bars, restaurants, Victorian hotels, boating, fishing, a Monument, caves, ice cream and so much more. For more information on the history of Put-in-Bay, we suggest you read Isolated Splendor by Robert Dodge where most of the information for this brief history page was obtained. Come visit South Bass Island, or Put-in-Bay as it is better known, and see for yourself all the things to do in Put-in-Bay.

Visitors are mainly from the local area such as Toledo, Cleveland, and Columbus but Put-in-Bay has recently been thriving as a regional Midwest staycation destination. More and more guests are arriving from Chicago, Detroit, Pittsburgh, Cincinnati, and Buffalo. There is even a large Canadian presence with tourists from Ontario Canada! Put-in-Bay, Ohio is popular.


Who Was Commodore Perry?

Commodore Oliver Hazard Perry (birth: August 23, 1785 -­ death: August 23, 1819) was an officer in the United States Navy. He served in the War of 1812 against Great Britain and earned the nickname “Hero of Lake Erie” for leading American forces in the decisive naval victory at the Battle of Lake Erie. He is the namesake behind the Memorial.

Oliver Hazard Perry

At his request during the War of 1812 he was given command of U.S. Naval forces on Lake Erie. He supervised the building of a small fleet at what is now Erie, Pennsylvania. On September 10, 1813 Perry’s fleet defended against an attacking British fleet at the Battle of Lake Erie. His battle report after victory is famous: “We have met the enemy and they are ours”. It made Put-in-Bay history.

The Battle of Lake Erie, sometimes also referred to as the Battle of Put-in-Bay, was fought on September 10, 1813 in Lake Erie off the coast of Ohio. It was between nine ships of the United States Navy and six vessels of Great Britain. The decisive victory of the Americans over the British fleet ensured American control of the lake and the North-Western Territory during the War of 1812, opened supply lines, and improved American morale after a series of U.S. defeats in the Great Lakes theater.

Perry’s Victory & International Peace Memorial

To commemorate the American naval triumph, Perry’s Victory & International Peace Memorial was constructed between 1912 and 1915 by a commission of nine states and the federal government. On June 2, 1936 the memorial was established as a unit of the National Park Service by a presidential proclamation of Franklin D. Roosevelt.

perrys victory international memorial

When you visit Put-in-Bay, take advantage of a golf cart rental to get around and see all the sights. The Monument is the biggest draw, but don’t forget about the Lake Erie Islands Historical Society museum which has many great exhibits from all the islands including North Bass, Middle Bass, and South Bass. So make your way to Port Clinton, jump on the Miller Ferry, choose one of the Put-in-Bay hotels to overnight, and prepare yourself for a historical adventure!