A shot of the Commodore Resort and MIST Pool Bar, during calm hours.

The Island Club Home Rentals and Commodore Resort offer on and off site Put-in-Bay event catering.  They can accommodate groups of up to 500 people.  The Resorts are conveniently located a short stroll from downtown Put-in-Bay.  The catering options are impressive. This includes flexible dining options such as indoor formal and poolside relaxed. So, with a wide variety of menu options and themes, the Put-in-Bay area has become the obvious choice for groups visiting the island.  Come and see for yourself.   Past customers have been satisfied with our service include:

Put-in-Bay Event Catering Options

Menus and styles reflect each individual group’s needs. Plated lunches and dinners are available.  Also, buffet style is available. We even do breakfast! The Commodore Resort offers relaxed poolside dining.  Here, guests have full use of the island’s best heated swim up bar and grill.  Bar service can be added as a host bar or cash bar.  So, each event is unique.  Much effort goes into the planning process.  You will not be disappointed.

At the resort guests can choose from a formal meal inside to a more casual service pool side.  So, options abound. Box lunches are available for school and day trippers.  Moreover, this is a great way to enjoy a relaxed luncheon at one of Put-in-Bay’s many attractions.  These include the South Bass Island State Park or Perry’s Victory and International Peace Memorial.  Furthermore, a boxed lunch will be a great value.  Otherwise, lunch may be costly for a large group.  So, consider this option for savings and convenience.  You’ll be glad you did.

To plan your next event, contact us. Then, our planners will assist you in organizing your Event Catering.  Also, they will aid with menus and transportation needs. For information, call 1-216-898-9951.


Sample Food Packages

South Bass Island Package ($32.95 per person)

Your choice of 3 smoked meats carved as you order:

Brisket * Ribs * Pulled Pork * ¼ Smoked Chicken * Hot Links

Your choice of 1 Salad:

House Salad * Potato Salad * Pasta Salad * Cole Slaw

Your choice of 2 Side Items:

Texas Toast * Baked Beans * Corn on Cob * Green Bean Casserole * Smashed Potatoes * Cajun Rice * Mixed Vegetables

Non-Alcoholic Beverages

Catawba Island Package ($28.95 per person)

(** 40-person minimum)

Slow Smoked Whole Pig, carved dinner-side

Your choice of 1 Salad ($1 extra/each for multiple salads):

House Salad * Potato Salad * Pasta Salad * Cole Slaw

Your choice of 1 Side Items ($2 extra/each for multiple sides):

Texas Toast * Baked Beans * Corn on the Cob * Mixed Veggies

Non-Alcoholic Beverages

Rattlesnake Island Package ($32.95 per person, Event Catering)

10oz Strip Steaks -or- Slow-Smoked 1/4 BBQ Chickens ($8 more for both)

Shrimp Skewers ($5.00 extra per person)

Baked Potato

Corn on the cob

Dinner Salad

Non-Alcoholic Beverages

Middle Bass Island Package ($29.95 per person)

Egg Rolls -or- Turkey Potstickers

Asian Mixed Greens with Soy Sesame Dressing

Vegetable Fried Rice

Steamed California Vegetable Medley

Grilled Plum Sauce Chicken Breast -or- Teriyaki Steak

Fortune Cookie

Non-Alcoholic Beverages

Gull Island Package ($28.95 per person)

Chicken & Beef Fajitas (build your own)

Spanish Rice

Mixed Greens with Southwest Ranch Dressing

Housemade Tortilla Chips, Guacamole, Sour Cream and Salsa

Refried Beans with Grated Cheddar & Onions

Warm Flour Tortillas

Non-Alcoholic Beverages

North Bass Island Package ($34.95 per person)

Lake Erie Yellow Perch

BBQ Pulled Pork Sandwiches

Salad Bar

Beer-Battered Brew City Fries

Pasta Salad

Assorted Condiments

Non-Alcoholic Beverages

Pelee Island Package ($19.95 per person, Event Catering)

Grilled Bratwurst

BBQ Chicken

¼ lb Cheeseburgers

Potato Salad

Ranch Style Beans

Corn Cobs – or – Corn Bread

Non-Alcoholic Beverages

Prime Rib Dinner ($29.95 per person)

Garden -or- Caesar Salad

Mashed Potatoes & Brown Gravy

Steamed Vegetables

Rolls & Butter

Non-Alcoholic Beverages

Smoked Pork Chops ($26.95 per person)

Stuffed with apple almond dressing

Mashed Potatoes & Cream Gravy

Green Bean Casserole

Rolls & Butter

Non-Alcoholic Beverages

Fried Chicken ($22.95 per person)

With Mashed Potatoes & Chicken Gravy

Corn on the Cob

Rolls & Butter

Non-Alcoholic Beverages

Chicken Parmesan with Spaghetti ($23.95 per person, Event Catering)

Served with House Salad

Garlic Toast

Non-Alcoholic Beverages

Children’s Dinner

Cup of Fruit

Macaroni and Cheese

Tater Tots

(choice of one entrée)

Breast of Chicken Tenders

– or –

Children’s Cheeseburger

3 years and under $7.95

4 to 12 years old $12.95

** All Prices Subject to 20% Service Charge and 8.75% Sales Tax


Sample A La Carte Hors D’ouevres

Scallops Wrapped In Bacon

Prosciutto Formaggio

Asst. Smoked Sausages

Assorted Quiche

Stuffed Mushrooms w/ Crab

White Stuffed Mushrooms w/ Sausage

Stuffed Mushrooms w/ Spinach

Smoked Turkey Wraps

Pepperoni Pinwheels

Crab Balls

Chicken Nuggets

Meatballs (Swedish, Sweet & Sour, Barbecue)

Spinach Cheese Balls

Chicken Fingers w/ Sauce

Mozzarella Sticks w/ Sauce

Fried Mushrooms

Chicken Egg Rolls

Pigs in the Blanket

Genoa Cornucopias

Pepper Shooters

Jalapeno Poppers

Seasonal Fresh Fruit Display

Bourbon Dogs

Spicy Hot Wings

Sliced Stromboli

Cheese Pierogies

Gourmet Cheese Display

Shrimp Cocktail (*Addl.Charge)

Lobster Ravioli (*Addl. Charge)

Seafood Bar (* Addl. Charge)

Crostini/ Dips

Chicken Taquitos

Sesame Chicken Tenders

Harvest Fresh Vegetable Crudite w/ Dip

Coconut Chicken Tenders

Hors D’ouevre Platters can be custom made to your specifications.

Please contact us so we can provide you a quote, based on your selections. Likewise, if you are interested in a food item that you do not see listed, please contact us for availability.


Bar Packages – Event Catering

Call Brands:

Absolut Vodka, Beefeater Gin, Captain Morgan Spiced Rum, Dewars, Seagram’s 7, Jose Cuervo Gold Tequila, Jack Daniel’s Bourbon

Premium Brands:

Ketel One Vodka, Bombay Sapphire Gin, Myer’s Dark Rum, Johnny Walker Black Scotch, Crown Royal Blended Whiskey, Jose Cuervo 1800 Tequila, Makers Mark Bourbon

All Banquet Open Bars include Red and White House Wine, Imported & Domestic Beers, Bottled Waters & Assorted Soft Drinks.

Host Bar on an Hourly Basis

Includes all Mixers, Liquors and Garnishes based on a per person basis.

Call Brands                                     1st Hour $18.00 per Guest       2nd Hour $14.00 per Guest

Premium Brands                          1st Hour $22.00 per Guest       2nd Hour $16.00 per Guest

Beer, Wine and Soda Only         1st Hour $15.00 per Guest       2nd Hour $12.00 per Guest

Hosted Bar on a Consumption Basis

Call Cocktails        $5.50               Premium Cocktails         $6.00

Imported Beer     $4.50              Domestic Beer                  $4.00

Variety Wines      $5.00              Bottled Water                   $3.00

Assorted Soda                  $2.00

** All Prices Subject to 20% Service Charge and 8.75% Sales Tax

Cash Bar Prices

* Tax included

Call Cocktails        $5.50               Premium Cocktails         $6.50

Imported Beer     $5.00              Domestic Beer                  $4.50

Variety Wines      $5.50              Bottled Water                   $3.50

Assorted Soda                  $2.50

Whether you choose a Cash Bar or a Sponsored Reception, $250.00 per Hour, per Bar of Revenue, must be generated. Otherwise, an additional charge of $75.00 per Hour, per Bartender, will be applied to Your Account. One bartender per 100 Guests.


Champagne Toast Packages – Event Catering

(prices include complete champagne service and are per person)

Local Island Wines

Heineman’s Sweet                                   $5.00

Mon Ami Spumante                                 $7.00

Mon Ami Extra Dry                                  $12.00

National Brands

Martini & Rossi Asti Spumante           $8.00

Piper Heidsieck Cuvee Brut                 $16.00

Quick Info:

1490 Put-in-Bay Rd, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456, United States