Put-In-Bay Restaurants

Some of the best memories with family and friends are made over a great meal. We get together for dinners to celebrate holidays, birthdays and more. A great meal can take your vacation with people you care about to another level. At Put-in-Bay, we have so many great dining choices, ranging from casual to upscale, and any style of cuisine you can think of. The only challenge will be trying all of the restaurants that sound good during your stay! Read on to learn more about all of the great choices for a meal when out at Put-in-Bay!

Swipe Right Pizza

Swipe Right Pizza

Swipe Right Pizza – Put-in-Bay, Ohio

Swipe Right Pizza is the island’s newest option to feed a hungry tummy. They do it with some awesome pizza that’s both hot & fresh. The best part? They do it for less than the big guys on Put-in-Bay, Ohio!

Each one of these delicious pizzas features legalized marinara sauce! You heard that right. It even says so on their pizza menu on their website!

The whimsical menu is fun to peruse and it is full of little surprises if you look hard enough. Swipe Right features signature pizzas such as the Lorena Bobbitt (featuring: mushrooms, onions, and banana pepper). The Lorena Bobbitt pizza is meatless, of course, so don’t ask for any. read more

Quick Info:
1402 Catawba Avenue, Put-in-Bay, OH, USA
419-742-9222

Mr. Ed’s Bar & Grille

mr eds bar and grille

Mr Ed’s Bar and Grille is a crowd favorite at Put-in-Bay.  This famous Put-in-Bay hotspot is not only one of the best places to grab a drink, it’s also the new home of Cameo Pizza. Cameo offers their specialty pizzas, chicken wings and more out of Mr. Ed’s kitchen. Diners can eat inside the bar, or opt for lunch on the outdoor patio.  So, at Mr Ed’s Bar and Grille there are options for everybody.  

The location of Mr. Ed’s is ideal, on the main street of Put-in-Bay.  Furthermore, the Delaware Avenue block has the majority of the shops, restaurants and attractions on the island.  Moreover, there are several different areas to enjoy at Mr. Ed’s.  First, the main floor bar features live entertainment nightly.  Here, guests can grab an incredible pizza and cold drink and enjoy some of the best entertainment on Put-in-Bay.  read more

Quick Info:
272 Delaware Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456, United States
419-285-3101

Green Room at Mr. Ed’s

greenroom

The Green Room at Mr. Ed’s is the premier spot for late night entertainment.  Dance the night away under the stars at this favorite rooftop bar.  Also, enjoy sweeping views of DeRivera Park and the downtown Put-in-Bay harbor.  Get with the beat, as the best DJ’s in the area keep the scene jumping.

Green Room Location

The home bar of this great Put-in-Bay hot spot is Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grille.  Mr. Ed’s has an outstanding location on the main strip.  Furthermore, the majority of the best Put-in-Bay Attractions and Shopping options are a short walk away.  Also, the Jet Express dock is just across the park, making this spot a must! read more

Quick Info:
300 Delaware Avenue, Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456, United States
(419) 285-5042

Joe’s Bar & Restaurant

joes bar and restaurant

Joe’s Bar and Restaurant is a local favorite hangout.  The atmosphere is inviting, putting patrons at ease.  Guests can expect to leave refreshed from Joe’s.

Finding the location is easy.  Joe’s is located on the corner of Meechen Road and Catawba Avenue.  South Bass Island State Park is a short walk away.  The building is very distinguishable with a striking red exterior.  Moreover, the structure has a rich and lively history.  Previously, the space was used as a press house for grapes.  The wine making traditions of Put-in-Bay run deep.  Here, the Doller press house, was integral in the wine production.  Today, Heineman’s Winery continues the tradition. read more

Quick Info:
1400 Catawba Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456, United States
419-285-5637

MIST Pool Bar

Mist

MIST Pool Bar is the island’s hottest wet spot!  Here, guests can immerse themselves in the beautiful setting.  The sounds of the waterfalls crashing sets the tone.  Swim right up for a hand crafted cocktail while enjoying the scene.  Weekends feature outstanding local DJ’s spinning tunes.  The scene is electric!  Weekdays offer a more relaxed vibe, a respite from the hustle of daily life.

Be sure to check the Entertainment Schedule, as great acts play on the pool deck throughout the season.

MIST Pool Bar Location

MIST is located behind Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grill.  Mr. Ed’s is situated in the heart of downtown Put-in-Bay on Delaware Avenue.  Also, the Subway Restaurant is just outside the gate for the pool bar.  This central location makes it very accessible from anywhere on the island. read more

Quick Info:
272 Delaware Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456, United States
419-341-2858

Subway

subway

Subway is the place to eat fresh on Put-in-Bay.  The location is in the lobby of the Commodore Resort.  The smells of freshly baked bread lure in customers.  Additionally, the variety of selections and value make this a visitor favorite.  Therefore, to save some funds during a Put-in-Bay visit, Subway is a viable option.

The Commodore Resort is situated just behind Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grille.  So, to find this sandwich shop from Delaware Ave., just look for the Subway sign in front of Mr. Ed’s.  Then, walk right down the alley for a sub made to order.  The choices are aplenty.  Opt for a Subway Club piled high with roast beef, turkey and ham.  Instead, go for the savory meatball sub, complete with hearty meatballs and marinara.  All subs can be personalized with a large selection of fresh vegetables and sauces. read more

Quick Info:
272 Delaware Ave, Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456, United States
419-285-5555

Last Resort Engine Company

Put-in-Bay Bar

Welcome to Put-in-Bay, Ohio. Have you ever looked at a firetruck and thought to yourself “I’d love to have myself a beer in there?” Well look no further, because Last Resort Engine Company is the bar of your dreams!

Last Resort Engine Company

Put-in-Bay Bar

This awesome Put-in-Bay bar is literally a firetruck turned into a bar. The truck itself is a 1980’s “LaFrance Pumper” and is actually still working condition despite its age. Although, now that its tank has been removed, it won’t be fighting fires anytime soon.

Another cool thing about the bar is the way they’ve been able to re purpose real firefighter gear in very creative ways. Some examples are how they turned used fire extinguishers into stools, incorporated used ladders into the awning, and used firefighter helmets lining the top. In fact, one of the helmets was actually used by the NYFD during the horrific 9/11 attacks. read more

Quick Info:
432 Catwaba Ave
(419) 285-5555

Cameo Pizza

cameo pizza

Cameo Pizza of Put-in-Bay prides themselves on using fresh ingredients. The crust and sauce is fresh, made daily.   So, diners can expect a fresh and tasty pizza every time.  Additionally, Cameo’s offers subs, wraps, salads and more.  There is a reason this has become a staple of Put-in-Bay.

The location of this favored eatery is in downtown Put-in-Bay on Catawba Avenue.  Put-in-Bay Town Hall, the Put-in-Bay Police Department and the Lake Erie Islands Historical Museum are just steps away.  Guests can opt to visit this location for carry out service.  Otherwise, delivery service is available.  Delivery hours plunge deep into the night during peak season, so there is always time to enjoy a Cameo pizza.  Late night service is available up to as late as 4 AM at the busiest of times. read more

Quick Info:
438 Catawba Avenue, Put-in-Bay, OH, United States
419-285-4444

Biergarten at the Boathouse

Biergarten at the Boathouse

The Biergarten at the Boathouse is a new and great addition to the Put-in-Bay Bar Scene.  Here, guests can choose from a fine selection of German beers and food.  Order an authentic German bratwurst and wash it down with a stein of authentic brew.  Other food choices include Bavarian pretzels and savory potato cakes.  A comfortable outdoor seating area is in the rear, beckoning guests for relaxation.

Biergarten at the Boathouse Location

Downtown Put-in-Bay is home to the Biergarten.  Furthermore, this is the first pub guests will encounter upon disembarking the Jet Express.  So, for the quickest beverage off the boat, this is the go-to spot.  Also, the beautiful DeRivera Park is across the street.  The rest of the great Put-in-Bay Bars and Attractions are very accessible from here. read more

Quick Info:
194 Hartford Avenue, Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456, United States
(419) 285-2113

Boardwalk Restaurant

boardwalk restaurant

The Boardwalk Restaurant has many tasty Put-in-Bay dining options.  Within the complex, there are a variety of food offerings.  Most notably, is their Lobster Bisque.  This restaurant is hailed as the Lobster Bisque Capital of Ohio. The Boardwalk has something for everyone.

The waterfront location affords guests with expansive views of Lake Erie and the downtown docks.  Additionally, sweeping vistas of downtown Put-in-Bay are sure to inspire.  This building on the shore is very distinguishable.

Boardwalk Restaurant- Dining Choices Galore!

The Boardwalk Restaurant is comprised of several different eateries.  On the main deck there are three distinct eateries.  First, the Fish Shack offers some of best fish of Lake Erie.  Fresh walleye and perch sandwiches are highlights.  Second, the Little Galley is a budget friendly option.  Families flock to this eatery for delicious burgers, hot dogs and more.  Lastly, Book’s Seafood offers a variety of exceptional seafood offerings.  Alaskan King Crab, Maine Lobster and Key West Pink Shrimp are a few of the notable menu items.  Additionally, there are two bars on the Main Deck.  The Burgee Bar and Claw Daddy’s await the thirsty traveler. read more

Quick Info:
341 Bayview Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH, United States
419-285-3695

Unique Put-in-Bay Dining and Cuisine

When you explore the Lake Erie Islands, local authentic cuisine will be discovered all over. Meals ranging from simple fresh lake fish enjoyed with a view of the Bay to high-end but casual restaurants like the Goat Soup and Whiskey and everything you would expect in between. You could eat in a different Put-in-Bay dining for every meal. You might ask yourself, Can you make reservations for Put-in-Bay Restaurants? Well, most of our dining choices are walk-in and no reservations are needed!

Superb Lake Erie game fish like walleye and perch is typical – you’ll get no fresher in the classiest restaurants in the world. Island entertainment in the evening is a must: beautiful dancing, traditional island guitar acts and mesmerizing steel drums. The crowd participation with the popular late-night DJs in our Put-in-Bay clubs and bars is a highlight. How many bars are in Put-in-Bay Ohio? Well over a dozen!

Seafood and Concerts

Surrounded by Lake Erie, the shallowest of the Great Lakes, local fishermen venture beyond the lighthouse before sunrise. Their catches help Put-in-Bay Dining earn a reputation for creating the best cuisine in the area. Fresh seafood comes straight out of the lake and is prepared simply by local chefs. They use delicious local ingredients from our nutrient-rich fresh island gardens. Many island chefs even grow their own herbs and vegetables for a truly Green dining experience. But don’t worry, there are quick service places serving great food to diners like Subway and the Chicken Patio, and the Burrito Stand.

You can even get some fair food at the annual Bash on the Bay country concert in Put n Bay Ohio. Past performers have been Toby Keith Put in Bay, Rascal Flatts Put in Bay, and Kid Rock Put in Bay tickets. Local hotels offer their own unique food offerings also such as the Islander Inn Put in Bay and the Bayshore Resort Put in Bay. And as an added bonus, if you book direct (instead of using Airbnb Put in Bay or VRBO Put in Bay), then you will usually save money that you can use for great dining on the island!

Love fresh food?

There are over forty places to eat and drink on the little island of Put-in-Bay. This page features just a few! Also check out more dining options at PutinbayDining.com. Or simply ask a Put-in-Bay taxi driver where he or she loves to eat, you may be surprised!

Seafood meals at the Boardwalk feature favorite local dishes like famous lobster bisque cooked in a traditional manner and served in a sourdough bread bowl. Try Hooligans on Catawba Ave for the freshest perch tacos on the island. Lake Erie Perch is a favorite at Mossbacks across from Derivera Park. Alaskan King Crab entrees makes an appearance when it is in season.

Breakfast, Lunch, and Dinner

Where to get Breakfast on Put-in-Bay? Start the day with a delicious breakfast of Eggs Benedict at Frosty Bar or Bloody Marys at Reel Bar. Or maybe try the omelets at Pasquale’s Cafe on Loraine Ave or crepes at the Forge. The Village Bakery is a hot spot for danishes and coffee unless you favor the margaritas across the street with live entertainment. Ice cream at Dairy Isle is always an option, any time of day.

A perfect lunch in downtown Put-in-Bay can be a simple burger and fries at the Boathouse Bar or a cuban sandwich at Topsy Turvey. Late-night street vendor dogs or Cameo pizza slices in Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grille on Delaware Ave, or even a fine restaurant menu and appetizers at Upper Deck but in a casual environment like Mama Marias (famous for their meatball subs). What is the number for Pizza on Put-in-Bay? Your best bet for late night free delivery is 419-285-4444.

As well as gourmet sandwiches, pizza and Caribbean conch fritters are on offer by the water’s edge, there are many colorful cafés serving light meals and your fix of great eatery coffee. Is there a brewery on Put-in-Bay? Yes, there is, and it called the Put-in-Bay Brewery! There is even a distillery at the Put-in-Bay Brewery with outdoor seating.

After Hours at Put-in-Bay

When the sun sets and you’ve had your fill of our delicious cuisine. The real party begins! There are plenty of things to do in Put-in-Bay.

When the sun goes down, the party heats up. Put-in-Bay restaurants and bars boast the best nightlife of all the Lake Erie islands. Mix with friendly locals and boaters in open-air bars, most on the downtown strip where cool island vibes and spectacular vistas await. Grab a drink and enjoy the bands, whether local live music or a stunning sunset over the water at the Keys or Boardwalk restaurant.

When you want to go large, head to one of our pumping nightclubs, or join a nightly Put-in-Bay Rolling Pub Tour where you pedal yourself to the party. Above all, while our Put-in-Bay Restaurant nightlife is exciting and exotic, it’s extremely safe and fun. Stay Overnight and enjoy the late-night festivities!