Put in Bay dairy-isle

Dairy Isle is the place to beat the heat with a refreshing ice cream treat.  Also, they have a tasty selection of sandwiches and wraps for a quick lunch.  Stop in with the family for a savory dessert.

Dairy Isle Location

Just steps from the Jet Express terminal is this tasty Put-in-Bay eatery.  Also, the Keys Restaurant is just behind the building.  The Keys offers a Carribbean inspired menu with delectable frozen drinks to pair with it.


Leonard C: “A very convenient casual fast food family friendly restaurant on Put-in-Bay. The servers were very friendly and courteous. Our food was fresh and delicious including the local fried perch. I highly recommend stopping by for lunch, dinner or a snack.”

Eric S: “Me and my family went in and the whole crew greeted us at the door. We got food first and it was amazing and still hot when we got it. After we ate we got ice cream and may I just say the banana split was the best thing I’ve ever had. My kids got the Oreo flurry and they wanted seconds. My wife got a twist cone and it was beautiful. I 100% recommend this place to eat at and for an after meal treat.”

Darrel L: “My husband and I wanted something sweet as we walked the downtown area of Put-in-Bay our first evening on the island. We stopped in Dairy Isle. My husband had a soft-serve cone with a chocolate coating. He was happy with the flavor of the ice cream. I was pleased to see fresh fruit smoothies on the menu. I had a peanut butter banana frosty. It was just what I needed to satisfy my craving.”

Pamela O: “We visited Put-In-Bay on a steamy day in August. Even riding on the golf cart, it was pretty hot out. We pulled into the Dairy Isle and ordered ice cream. My husband had a banana split, while I had a vanilla cone. They offer free refills on fountain drinks, but the soft drinks are not self-serve. There’s also a water cooler in the lobby, which was exactly what I needed to refill my favorite Contigo cup. Service was fast, courteous and the restaurant was air conditioned.”