Frosty Bar Gifts

frosty bar gifts

Frosty Bar Gifts is the place to find your Frosty’s gear.  Frosty Bar has a prime location in downtown Put-in-Bay.  Specialties include their famous pizza and icy cold beer in a chilled mug.  An island tradition, Frosty’s is a must stop for many island travelers.  Taking home a memento is ideal.

The Gifts Shop

This gift shop has gifts for all sizes and ages.  There are t shirts, hoodies, coffee mugs and more.  The easily recognizable Frosty Bar logo adorns each item.  Additionally, kids sizes are available, so even the little ones can represent this local favorite.  Come and get a special reminder of an island outing.  Then, you’ll have lasting memories for the whole year.

About Frosty Bar and Pizza

This Put-in-Bay island institution has been in business for many years.  Guests come for their legendary pizza.  Pizza is thick crust with toppings piled high.  Furthermore, salads, bread sticks and subs complete the menu.  Fortunately, there is a fully stocked bar to wash down the delicious eats.  More importantly, draft beer comes in icy cold mugs.  Frosty Bar is also well known as a place to catch the big game.  Multiple televisions line the walls, playing the latest sports offerings. So, come root on your team.  Be sure to wear your team colors. Join in on the fun!

Frosty Bar Dining Options

The dining options go beyond the tasty pizza.  In the rear of the building, Big Man’s Burrito Stand and Frosty’s Backyard welcomes guests.  Here, guests can order burritos to order with all the fixings.  Additionally, nachos with queso and guacamole are a notable menu item.  A late night burrito may be what’s needed to face the next day.  Live music and Dj’s also frequent the establishment, setting the right mood.  So, come to Frosty Bar for cold drinks and hot eats, right in the heart of Put-in-Bay.  This is close to nearly all the island attractions and shopping.  Additionally, the Jet Express dock is a short walk away.  So, with great eats and location, Frosty’s is a must!


Mackenzie D: “Best bar & restaurant on the island, hands down!! Perfect for all 3 meals, Breakfast- amazing service & blueberry pancakes! Lunch- enjoy a walking taco out on the back patio, while watching a live band. Dinner – get that pepperoni pizza, and enjoy a cold one while watching a live band or sports game inside!!”

Christine K: “Such a historic building with a beautiful bar area and creative, seasonal mixed drinks available. I had the tasty Dog Pound Punch, with a part of the proceeds going to the Humane Society. Good beers on tap and breakfast options, too!”

Josh S: “If you’re not into the night life, this is still a great place to go to for breakfast. I think it’s the best breakfast in town. there is a server there named Derek. If you need info on anything going on in Put In Bay, just ask him. He has been here for a long time and he will take the time to share his knowledge with you.”


Making a trip to Put-in-Bay is a must in the Summer months.  With a multitude of attractions, shops and dining options, there is something for everyone.  Moreover, to get the most out of an island adventure, considering staying the night.  Lodging options are aplenty.  Choices include hotels, homes and condos.  So, what are you waiting for?  Book a stay today.

Quick Info:
252 Delaware Ave, Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456, United States