Put-in-Bay Pizza Company

put-in-bay pizza company

The Put-in-Bay Pizza Company is the islands preferred pizza provider.  Hungry travelers can find this location at the Put-in-Bay Resort and Conference Center.  The full service Blue Marlin Tiki Bar is next to the pizza shop.  So, stroll in for a piping hot pizza and a cold beverage.

Put-in-Bay Pizza Company Menu Highlights

The fresh selections are impressive.  Standout selections include the pizza and massive grinders.  Notable specialty pizzas include the Chicken Bacon Ranch, Chicken Alfredo and Hawaiian Pizzas. The grinder sandwiches are exceptional.  Choices include the Fajita Chicken and Italian.  Needless to say, diners will leave happy and satisfied. Additionally, the menu has great choices to compliment the pizza offerings.  Fresh salads like Chef’s Italian or Chicken Salad are sure to delight.  Lastly, don’t forget about the savory Chicken Wings.  Wing dings come in a variety of delicious sauces.  It’s hard to pick just one!

The Put-in-Bay Pizza Company offers free delivery.  So, anywhere on the island can get a fresh pie delivered.  Also, this location is open late to satisfy the late night hunger.  Eating here is very economical.  Guests can expect great savings as opposed to many of the other island options.  Still, guests won’t sacrifice taste for savings.  Moreover, the fresh and savory selections at the Put-in-Bay Pizza Company are sure to delight.  Grab some grub on your next island jaunt.

Stay at Put-in-Bay

A day trip to the island is a great way to get acclimated.  However, nothing can compare to staying.  The Put-in-Bay Resort and Conference Center has all of the comforts and features guests need.  There are lodging options for groups of all sizes.  The onsite Blue Marlin Tiki Bar and Put-in-Bay Pizza Co are very convenient.  See you at the Bay.


Justin F: “Best pizza on the island bar none hands down. If your looking for quality over quantity then you’ll go to this place. This place is definitely the best pizza on the island!”

Mina A: “They have great pizzas and subs with a wide variety of very delicious foods. I highly recommend it; the best place on Put-in-Bay to eat & drink.”

TJ: “The pizza was excellent! Staff was friendly an courteous I would visit again and recommend to anyone.”

Vince I: “My friends and I were tired after a long day. The delivery person was at our hotel dropping off another pizza and we ordered last minute. She was so friendly to take our order and deliver the pizza to us fresh, hot and delicious!”

Deborah O: “Sitting by the pool at our hotel, we didn’t want to get up for lunch. Ordered a pizza from the Put-In-Bay Pizza Company. It was ready within 30 minutes and all four in our group really liked the pizza.”

Quick Info:
439 Loraine Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH, United States