Put-In-Bay Restaurants

Some of the best memories with family and friends are made over a great meal. We get together for dinners to celebrate holidays, birthdays and more. A great meal can take your vacation with people you care about to another level. At Put-in-Bay, we have so many great dining choices, ranging from casual to upscale, and any style of cuisine you can think of. The only challenge will be trying all of the restaurants that sound good during your stay! Read on to learn more about all of the great choices for a meal when out at Put-in-Bay!

The Roundhouse Bar

round house put in bay

The Roundhouse Bar at Put-in-Bay is an island institution steeped in tradition.  Thousands have flocked to this favorite watering hole for over 140 years.  The character and feel once inside, makes this a must stop.

Roundhouse Bar History

The Columbia Restaurant was open in downtown Put-in-Bay in June of 1873.  Here, guests chose from a selection of beer, wine and food. Most notably, was ice cream and cottage cheese.  In this time, these choices were sought after. Additionally, in this era, there wasn’t electricity in the building.  So, in the Winter blocks of ice came from the lake. Then, the ice house at the present day Put-in-Bay Winery held the ice. Prominent banners stretched across the street advertising ice cream treats. Then, in 1888 the first mention of the Roundhouse name surfaced in a newspaper article.  Also, the article listed George F. Schmidt as one the early owners. read more

Quick Info:
258 Delaware Avenue, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456, USA
419-285-2323

South Bass Taphouse

southbasstaphouse

South Bass Taphouse is one of the newest bars on Put-in-Bay.  Here, guests can choose from an impressive selection of craft brews and cocktails.  Also, the numerous television screens provide a great spot to catch the game.

South Bass Taphouse Location

The Catawba Avenue corridor is home to this great bar.  The Old Forge, Put-in-Bay Brewing Company and Reel Bar are right across the street.  This area has grown to become an extension of the main Delaware Avenue strip.

Testimonials

Francine M: “Had a great time! Energy and people were tops as was service and drinks! Loved the atmosphere, it is true island style and WELL WORTH your time! We went out to the Bay as part of a girl’s weekend from Florida, Colorado, Ohio and Tennessee and it rocked thanks to this hot spot! Highly recommend!” read more

Quick Info:

Tippers Steak House

tippers steak house dining

“Put-in-Bay has many restaurants open during the summer catering to all of the visitors on the island. Tippers Steak House is well known for the quality of their beef and their incredible weekly specials. But in the winter months there has only been a couple restaurants open to serve the 150 or so island residents. Tippers Steak House is one of them. Or should we say, it was one of them.

Island on Ice

As you may or may not know, Put-in-Bay is on an island (South bass Island) and the lake (Lake Erie) ices over in the winter. So the only way to get off or on the island is by airplane after the ferry stops running. This locks in the island residents who enjoy a very quiet winter. Only a few community events such as school sports and town hall meetings provide social outlets, other than Tippers. read more

Quick Info:
419-285-8477

Topsey Turvey

Topsey Turvey

Topsey Turvey is a waterfront bar with spectacular views and great eats and drinks.  Stop by for a Bloody Mary, one of their most popular offerings.  Also, hearty Cuban and Reuben sandwiches are sure to fill the hungriest of travelers.

Topsey Turvey Location

Directly on Lake Erie in beautiful downtown Put-in-Bay is where you’ll find this great establishment.  The Jet Express terminal is just a short stroll down the sidewalk.  Also, the Sonny S ferry to Middle Bass Island is just steps outside.

Testimonials

Erin C: “We ate here for the first time ever. We have come to the island for years and said let’s try it. Jane was our waitress and she recommended the perch, so glad we tried it. By far the best one on the island. I tired the portobello boy and it was so good. We love this place so much we came back on our last night and lucked out to sit on the patio and watch the sunset and we had Jane as our waitress again. We tried the Cuban and had another perch sandwich. This is our new favorite place!” read more

Quick Info:
361 E Bayview Dr Put-In-Bay, OH 43452
(419) 285-4511

Village Bakery

put in bay village bakery

The Village Bakery on Put-in-Bay has fresh goodies daily.  Also, even the coffee beans get ground daily. So, a cup of java is excellent.  Fresh, fast and friendly best describe this island favorite.  Come find out for yourself.

The bakery location is very accessible.  Delaware Avenue is home to this island favorite.  Moreover, the Put-in-Bay bus depot is directly next door.  Also, Perry’s Victory and International Peace Memorial is prominently in view from the outside patio.  This monument is a testament to winning the Battle of 1812.  Oliver Hazard Perry led his men to battle.  The famous saying, “Don’t Give Up the Ship,” comes from Perry.  Also, the nations involved celebrate peace with this monument.  So, overall the Bakery location is superb.  Find the way to fresh.    read more

Quick Info:
104 Delaware Ave, Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456, United States
419.285.5351

Upper Deck

boardwalk upper deck restaurant

The Upper Deck is located within the Boardwalk Restaurant building on Put-in-Bay.  Here, diners can take in the sweeping views of Lake Erie.  Moreover, table side service is available on this level.

The Boardwalk Restaurant is an island food destination.  Diners come hungry and leave satisfied.  The location of the restaurant is superb.  Bayview Avenue in downtown Put-in-Bay is the home of the Boardwalk.  Nearby, the Put-in-Bay Winery and Jet Express terminal are a short walk away.  Also, the lovely DeRivera Park is just across the street.  Boaters are also welcomed here.  There are mooring buoys to dock.  Also, their is a water taxi to whisk boaters ashore.  So, no matter the choice of transportation, this restaurant is very accessible. read more

Quick Info:
341 Bayview Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456, United States
419-285-3695

Blue Marlin Tiki Bar & Grill

blue marlin

The Blue Marlin Tiki Bar & Grill is the place for fun and excitement at Put-in-Bay.  This pool bar is located at the Put-in-Bay Resort and Conference Center. Fortunately, the fun isn’t just reserved for hotel guests.  The public is welcome to come and enjoy the many great features.

The Put-in-Bay Resort and Conference Center is the premier hotel lodging choice of the island.  Features include well-appointed guest rooms and villas, a large swim up bar and massive hot tub.  Additionally, there are splash pad areas in the front of the Put-in-Bay villas.  Kids and kids at heart will love frolicking in this play space.  Also, the resort is proud to be the only Resort that has Conference facilities onsite. read more

Quick Info:
439 Loraine Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH, United States

Put-in-Bay Pizza Company

put-in-bay pizza company

The Put-in-Bay Pizza Company is the islands preferred pizza provider.  Hungry travelers can find this location at the Put-in-Bay Resort and Conference Center.  The full service Blue Marlin Tiki Bar is next to the pizza shop.  So, stroll in for a piping hot pizza and a cold beverage.

Put-in-Bay Pizza Company Menu Highlights

The fresh selections are impressive.  Standout selections include the pizza and massive grinders.  Notable specialty pizzas include the Chicken Bacon Ranch, Chicken Alfredo and Hawaiian Pizzas. The grinder sandwiches are exceptional.  Choices include the Fajita Chicken and Italian.  Needless to say, diners will leave happy and satisfied. Additionally, the menu has great choices to compliment the pizza offerings.  Fresh salads like Chef’s Italian or Chicken Salad are sure to delight.  Lastly, don’t forget about the savory Chicken Wings.  Wing dings come in a variety of delicious sauces.  It’s hard to pick just one! read more

Quick Info:
439 Loraine Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH, United States

Buckeye Tiki Bar

Buckeye Tiki Bar

The Buckeye Tiki Bar home is at the Bay Lodging Resort.  Here, guests can get away from the bustle of downtown Put-in-Bay.  However, the fun and excitement is just a short stroll away.

The Bay Lodging Resort is down a quiet street near the Village of Put-in-Bay.  This casual resort is a favorite among island guests.  Free wifi, continental breakfast and great location are a few of the attractive features.  Also, there are golf cart rentals available.  There is no better way to explore the island.  Guests often comment on the number of carts scurrying about.  Golf carts often sell out, so reserving one is highly recommended. read more

Quick Info:
405 Lakeview Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH, United States

Unique Put-in-Bay Dining and Cuisine

When you explore the Lake Erie Islands, local authentic cuisine will be discovered all over. Meals ranging from simple fresh lake fish enjoyed with a view of the Bay to high-end but casual restaurants like the Goat Soup and Whiskey and everything you would expect in between. You could eat in a different Put-in-Bay dining for every meal. You might ask yourself, Can you make reservations for Put-in-Bay Restaurants? Well, most of our dining choices are walk-in and no reservations are needed!

Superb Lake Erie game fish like walleye and perch is typical – you’ll get no fresher in the classiest restaurants in the world. Island entertainment in the evening is a must: beautiful dancing, traditional island guitar acts and mesmerizing steel drums. The crowd participation with the popular late-night DJs in our Put-in-Bay clubs and bars is a highlight. How many bars are in Put-in-Bay Ohio? Well over a dozen!

Seafood and Concerts

Surrounded by Lake Erie, the shallowest of the Great Lakes, local fishermen venture beyond the lighthouse before sunrise. Their catches help Put-in-Bay Dining earn a reputation for creating the best cuisine in the area. Fresh seafood comes straight out of the lake and is prepared simply by local chefs. They use delicious local ingredients from our nutrient-rich fresh island gardens. Many island chefs even grow their own herbs and vegetables for a truly Green dining experience. But don’t worry, there are quick service places serving great food to diners like Subway and the Chicken Patio, and the Burrito Stand.

You can even get some fair food at the annual Bash on the Bay country concert in Put n Bay Ohio. Past performers have been Toby Keith Put in Bay, Rascal Flatts Put in Bay, and Kid Rock Put in Bay tickets. Local hotels offer their own unique food offerings also such as the Islander Inn Put in Bay and the Bayshore Resort Put in Bay. And as an added bonus, if you book direct (instead of using Airbnb Put in Bay or VRBO Put in Bay), then you will usually save money that you can use for great dining on the island!

Love fresh food?

There are over forty places to eat and drink on the little island of Put-in-Bay. This page features just a few! Also check out more dining options at PutinbayDining.com. Or simply ask a Put-in-Bay taxi driver where he or she loves to eat, you may be surprised!

Seafood meals at the Boardwalk feature favorite local dishes like famous lobster bisque cooked in a traditional manner and served in a sourdough bread bowl. Try Hooligans on Catawba Ave for the freshest perch tacos on the island. Lake Erie Perch is a favorite at Mossbacks across from Derivera Park. Alaskan King Crab entrees makes an appearance when it is in season.

Breakfast, Lunch, and Dinner

Where to get Breakfast on Put-in-Bay? Start the day with a delicious breakfast of Eggs Benedict at Frosty Bar or Bloody Marys at Reel Bar. Or maybe try the omelets at Pasquale’s Cafe on Loraine Ave or crepes at the Forge. The Village Bakery is a hot spot for danishes and coffee unless you favor the margaritas across the street with live entertainment. Ice cream at Dairy Isle is always an option, any time of day.

A perfect lunch in downtown Put-in-Bay can be a simple burger and fries at the Boathouse Bar or a cuban sandwich at Topsy Turvey. Late-night street vendor dogs or Cameo pizza slices in Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grille on Delaware Ave, or even a fine restaurant menu and appetizers at Upper Deck but in a casual environment like Mama Marias (famous for their meatball subs). What is the number for Pizza on Put-in-Bay? Your best bet for late night free delivery is 419-285-4444.

As well as gourmet sandwiches, pizza and Caribbean conch fritters are on offer by the water’s edge, there are many colorful cafés serving light meals and your fix of great eatery coffee. Is there a brewery on Put-in-Bay? Yes, there is, and it called the Put-in-Bay Brewery! There is even a distillery at the Put-in-Bay Brewery with outdoor seating.

After Hours at Put-in-Bay

When the sun sets and you’ve had your fill of our delicious cuisine. The real party begins! There are plenty of things to do in Put-in-Bay.

When the sun goes down, the party heats up. Put-in-Bay restaurants and bars boast the best nightlife of all the Lake Erie islands. Mix with friendly locals and boaters in open-air bars, most on the downtown strip where cool island vibes and spectacular vistas await. Grab a drink and enjoy the bands, whether local live music or a stunning sunset over the water at the Keys or Boardwalk restaurant.

When you want to go large, head to one of our pumping nightclubs, or join a nightly Put-in-Bay Rolling Pub Tour where you pedal yourself to the party. Above all, while our Put-in-Bay Restaurant nightlife is exciting and exotic, it’s extremely safe and fun. Stay Overnight and enjoy the late-night festivities!