Put-In-Bay Restaurants

Some of the best memories with family and friends are made over a great meal. We get together for dinners to celebrate holidays, birthdays and more. A great meal can take your vacation with people you care about to another level. At Put-in-Bay, we have so many great dining choices, ranging from casual to upscale, and any style of cuisine you can think of. The only challenge will be trying all of the restaurants that sound good during your stay! Read on to learn more about all of the great choices for a meal when out at Put-in-Bay!

The Keys

the keys put in bay

The Keys Restaurant brings Florida to Put-in-Bay.  Key West is well represented at this waterfront restaurant.  So, slow down and enjoy the island breezes.

A waterfront location makes the Keys an excellent choice.  Located in downtown Put-in-Bay next to the Jet Express dock, it is easy to find. Also, Perry’s Victory and International Peace Memorial is within view.  Moreover, this monument relates to the Battle of Lake Erie.  Oliver Hazard Perry was victorious, protecting the island from invasion.  Additionally, the monument serves as a testament to the ever lasting peace between the countries. read more

Quick Info:
227 Bayview Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH, United States
419-285-5397

Little Galley

little galley restaurant

The Little Galley on Put-in-Bay is part of the Boardwalk family of restaurants.  Families should take note of this eatery.  Morevoer, they feature affordable dining options for a trip to the island.

A waterfront location affords guests of the Little Galley exceptional views.  Furthermore, the Boardwalk Restaurant is located on Bayview Avenue in downtown Put-in-Bay.  Panoramic views of Lake Erie, the downtown docks and DeRivera Park abound.  Also, boaters can visit via the mooring buoys.  So, there are several options to make your way.

Little Galley Menu Highlights

This is the place to go for a quick and affordable lunch.  Moreover, menu highlights include classic Americana fare.  Black Angus burgers, chicken tenders and hot dogs are notable choices.  Also, piping hot french fries are served.  Add some zest to your meal with a selection of dipping sauces. read more

Quick Info:
341 Bayview Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH, United States
419-285-3695

Lolas Key

lolaskey

Lola’s Key at the Keys Restaurant complex features a gorgeous waterfront setting on Lake Erie.  Enjoy the lake breezes while enjoying a Fat Tuesday brand frozen concoction.  The Keys is the only establishment to offer these popular beverages.

Lola’s Key Location

After stepping off the Jet Express ferry, Lola’s Key is directly to the left of the dock.  There is ample seating at the bar and at tables perched just feet from the water.  Also, take in spectacular views of Perry’s Monument from this location.  Grab a savory appetizer and tasty beverage while enjoying the lovely setting.  From here, guests can traverse across DeRivera Park to the downtown Put-in-Bay area.  Here, most of the great attractions and shopping choices are found.  Stop in at Lola’s Key for great eats and stunning vistas. read more

Quick Info:
227 Bayview Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456, United States
(419) 285-5397

Mama Maria’s

Put in Bay mama-marias

Mama Marias Pizza has hearty meals for hungry travelers.  This Italian inspired eatery is fast and convenient. Options include impressive meatball subs, tasty wraps and delicious pizza.  Late night eats are very popular here.

Mama Marias Location

Delaware Avenue is the heart of the island.  This is where you’ll find these great eats.  Nearby, the Jet Express terminal is just a short walk away.  So, grabbing a quick bite when departing the island is very easy.  Next door to Mama Maria’s is one of the most popular establishments on the island, Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grille.

Testimonials

Mallory R: “Yum! Loved getting pizza here, ordered the family meal to go and it was delicious! Ordered a large pizza, breadsticks, family size salad and sodas for less than $30. Worked out great for us since Frosty’s next door was closed for the holiday.” read more

Quick Info:
266 Delaware Avenue, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456, United States
(419) 285-7400

Mojito Bay

Put in Bay Mojito Bay

Mojito Bay is a striking structure in the downtown Put-in-Bay area.  This beautiful tiki hut features swings instead of bar stools.  Moreover, construction occurred with authentic techniques by skilled craftsmen.  Swing up for a freshly muddled mojito.  There is an extensive list of options.  Also, there is great live entertainment on the main stage throughout the season.

Mojito Bay Location

This bar has a perfect island setting on Catawba Avenue.  The corridor is a natural extension to the main Delaware Avenue strip.  Mojito Bay is right at this intersection.   So, this is a great bar to begin the night.  The majority of the best Put-in-Bay Attractions and Shopping are nearby.  Moreover, they are within short walking distance. read more

Quick Info:
389 Catawba Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456, United States
(419) 285-4677

Mossbacks

Put in Bay mossbacks

Mossbacks Restaurant of Put-in-Bay has quality eats and tasty drinks.  Diners can opt for breakfast, lunch or dinner.  Also, the bar is a welcoming place to enjoy a carefully crafted libation.

The location of Mossbacks is prime.  Located nearest to Lake Erie on Catawba Avenue, the views are impressive.  Additionally, DeRivera Park is across the street.  Here, this beautiful waterfront park is the focal point of the downtown area. There are multiple children’s play areas, picnic tables and walking paths.  Also, the Jet Express ferry terminal is just a short walk away.

Mossbacks Menu Highlights

Menu options are a plenty.  First, the breakfast options are appetizing.  Eggs to order, pancakes and breakfast sandwiches are delectable options. Wash down the tasty fare with a Bloody Mary or Breakfast Bomb.  The Breakfast Bomb features Jameson Whiskey and Butterscotch Schnapps with an OJ chaser. Start the day off right with a hearty breakfast. read more

Quick Info:
371 Catawba Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH, United States
419-285-8888

Nagoya at the Keys

Put-in-Bay Nagoya at the Keys

Settle in for some fresh sushi at Nagoya at the Keys.  Nagoya is a wildly popular Japanese hibachi restaurant with two locations in northwest Ohio.  They have partnered with the Keys to offer guests of Put-in-Bay exceptional sushi.

Nagoya at the Keys Location

The Keys is a great waterfront eatery with options for everyone.  They are located directly next to the Jet Express docks.  Also, the docks of the Park Place Boat Club flank the waterfront of the building.  Impressive views of Perry’s Monument can be enjoyed from this Put-in-Bay Restaurant.

Quick Info:
227 Bayview Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456, United States
(419) 285-5397

Old Forge

Put in Bay Old Forge

The Old Forge is an excellent choice for breakfast, lunch or dinner on Put-in-Bay.  Their specialty is crepes, offering both sweet and savory selections.  Also, there is an impressive menu of breakfast options.  Pair your sweet crepe with a refreshing mimosa.  Stop by for a delectable wrap, sandwich or fresh salad for lunch.  No matter the selection, the food is fresh and delicious!

Old Forge Location

The Catawba Avenue corridor is home to the Old Forge.  This area has quickly grown over the past 10 years.  Now, this section has grown to become a natural extension of the downtown Put-in-Bay area.  The majority of the Put-in-Bay Attractions and Shopping options are within walking distance. read more

Quick Info:
451 Catawba Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456, United States
(419) 285-0022

Pasquale’s

Put in Bay pasquale's

Pasquale’s Family Restaurant has been serving the best breakfast on Put-in-Bay for over 20 years. The popularity can be easily verified by seeing the long lines waiting outside every weekend morning. Over the years, the building has been an ice cream shop, barbershop, and U.S. Customs Office. However, the current family-friendly restaurant is the tastiest option.  Still, the history of the building is quite interesting.  Additionally, there is a fantastic view of DeRivera Park and downtown Put-in-Bay to enjoy.  Breakfast, lunch and dinner is available.  Also, a children’s menu is available. read more

Quick Info:
234 Delaware Ave, Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456, United States
419-285-8600

Put-in-Bay Brewing Company

put-in-bay brewery

The Put-in-Bay Brewing Company has great eats and local beers to delight.  Every summer an impressive rotation of craft brews is produced. Also, the menu pairs nicely with the assortment.  So, stopping here for a bite is a true taste of the Lake Erie Islands.

Catawba Avenue is home to the Brewery.  The location is just around the corner from Delaware Avenue, the main thoroughfare of the island.  Here, the majority of Put-in-Bay attractions, shopping and dining can be found.  Also, the Jet Express terminal is just a short stroll away.  So, the location is ideal, near most of the offerings.

Put-in-Bay Brewing Company Menu Highlights

Diners can choose from a variety of attractive options.  Lunch and dinner service are provided.  Also, be sure to pair the meal with one of the exceptional craft beers. read more

Quick Info:
441 Catawba Ave, Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456, United States
419-285-4677

Unique Put-in-Bay Dining and Cuisine

When you explore the Lake Erie Islands, local authentic cuisine will be discovered all over. Meals ranging from simple fresh lake fish enjoyed with a view of the Bay to high-end but casual restaurants like the Goat Soup and Whiskey and everything you would expect in between. You could eat in a different Put-in-Bay dining for every meal. Superb Lake Erie game fish like walleye and perch is typical – you’ll get no fresher in the classiest restaurants in the world. Island entertainment in the evening is a must: beautiful dancing, traditional island guitar acts and mesmerizing steel drums. The crowd participation with the popular late-night DJs in our Put-in-Bay clubs and bars is a highlight.

Surrounded by Lake Erie, the shallowest of the Great Lakes, local fishermen venture beyond the lighthouse before sunrise. Their catches help Put-in-Bay Dining earn a reputation for creating the best cuisine in the area. Fresh seafood comes straight out of the lake and isprepared simply by local chefs. They use delicious local ingredients from our nutrient-rich fresh island gardens. Many island chefs even grow their own herbs and vegetables for a truly Green dining experience.

Love fresh food?

There are over forty places to eat and drink on the little island of Put-in-Bay. This page features just a few! Also check out more dining options at PutinbayDining.com. Or simply ask a Put-in-Bay taxi driver where he or she loves to eat, you may be surprised!

Seafood meals at the Boardwalk feature favorite local dishes like perch fish tacos, and lobster bisque cooked in a traditional matter and served in a sourdough bread bowl. A perfect lunch can be a simple burger and fries, late-night street vendor dogs or pizza slices or even a fine restaurant menu in a casual environment. As well as gourmet sandwiches, pizza and conch fritters are on offer by the water’s edge, there are many colorful cafés serving light meals and your fix of great coffee.

After Hours at Put-in-Bay

When the sun sets and you’ve had your fill of our delicious cuisine. The real party begins! There are plenty of things to do in Put-in-Bay.

When the sun goes down, the party heats up. Put-in-Bay restaurants and bars boast the best nightlife of all the Lake Erie islands. Mix with friendly locals and boaters in open-air bars, most on the downtown strip where cool island vibes and spectacular vistas await. Grab a drink and enjoy the bands, whether local live music or a stunning sunset over the water at the Keys or Boardwalk restaurant.

When you want to go large, head to one of our pumping nightclubs, or join a nightly Put-in-Bay Rolling Pub Tour where you pedal yourself to the party. Above all, while our Put-in-Bay Restaurant nightlife is exciting and exotic, it’s extremely safe and fun. Stay Overnight and enjoy the late-night festivities!