Put-In-Bay Restaurants

Some of the best memories with family and friends are made over a great meal. We get together for dinners to celebrate holidays, birthdays and more. A great meal can take your vacation with people you care about to another level. At Put-in-Bay, we have so many great dining choices, ranging from casual to upscale, and any style of cuisine you can think of. The only challenge will be trying all of the restaurants that sound good during your stay! Read on to learn more about all of the great choices for a meal when out at Put-in-Bay!

Dairy Isle

Put in Bay dairy-isle

Dairy Isle is the place to beat the heat with a refreshing ice cream treat.  Also, they have a tasty selection of sandwiches and wraps for a quick lunch.  Stop in with the family for a savory dessert.

Dairy Isle Location

Just steps from the Jet Express terminal is this tasty Put-in-Bay eatery.  Also, the Keys Restaurant is just behind the building.  The Keys offers a Carribbean inspired menu with delectable frozen drinks to pair with it.

Testimonials

Leonard C: “A very convenient casual fast food family friendly restaurant on Put-in-Bay. The servers were very friendly and courteous. Our food was fresh and delicious including the local fried perch. I highly recommend stopping by for lunch, dinner or a snack.” read more

Quick Info:
213 Bayview Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456, United States
(419) 285-3506

Dan Dee’s Snack Shack

Put in Bay DanDee's Snack Shack

Dan Dee’s Snack Shack has tasty food and drinks at reasonable prices.  Stop in for a quick snack or lunch during your outing to Put-in-Bay.  Options include chicken tenders, corn dogs, french fries and onion rings.  Also, opt for a icy cold slush to cool off from the Summer heat.

Dan Dee’s Snack Shack Location

Perry’s Cave and Family Fun Center is home to the Snack Shack.  This location offers an assortment of wonderful activities for kids and kids at heart.  Challenge friends to a game of mini golf at the War of 18 Holes.  Sift through a bag of rough mix and uncover gems and fossils at Gem Stone Mining.  There truly is a fun activity for the whole family. read more

Quick Info:
979 Catawba Avenue, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456, United States
(419) 285-2283

Fish Shack

Put in Bay fish shak

The Boardwalk Restaurant complex is home to the Fish Shack.  Here, diners can try some local fare.  Most notably, the Lake Erie Walleye and Yellow Perch are exceptional.  Fortunately, for those who do not care for seafood, other eateries reside within the building.  These stands feature hamburgers, chicken tenders and more.

Fish Shack Location and Island Views

The Boardwalk Restaurant is a pillar of the dining options on the island of Put in Bay.  A waterfront location affords guests panoramic views of Lake Erie.  Also, the neighboring islands of Gibraltar and Middle Bass Island can are visible from the outdoor terraces.

The Ohio State University owns Gibraltar Island. Moreover, they have been conducting fresh water research here for over 100 years.  Additionally, the islands history is rich with prominent guests visiting the island. Jay Cooke, a civil war financier, once owned the island.  Several US Presidents and other dignitaries spent time on Gibraltar Island.  Also, Cooke ordered the construction of what became known as Cooke Castle.  From the Fish Shack diners can view this spectacular structure.  In 1865 the project completed. Today, OSU is working on restoring the building to its original splendor. read more

Quick Info:
341 Bayview Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH, United States
419-285-3695

The Fish Bowl

fishbowl bar

The Fish Bowl on Put-in-Bay is a favored hangout among visitors.  The building was extensively renovated, providing guests with a comfortable and cozy environment.  Moreover, the expanded deck on South side of the building affords wondrous views of downtown Put-in-Bay.

Mossbacks is directly next to the Fishbowl.  The Valentine Doller building is home to both of these establishments.  Valentine Doller is a past resident of Put-in-Bay who came to the island in the mid 1800’s.  Moreover, during his time on the island he held many positions.  Surprisingly, he was the first postmaster, the clerk of courts, a founding trustee of the Village and even the mayor. This structure that bears his name is situated on Catawba Avenue.  Also, the beautiful DeRivera Park is across the street.  Additionally, the Jet Express ferry terminal is just a short walk away. read more

Quick Info:
371 Northwest Catawba Road, Put-in-Bay, OH, United States
419-285-3833

The Goat Soup & Whiskey

The Goat Soup and Whiskey Dining

The Goat Soup & Whiskey on Put-in-Bay is a choice eatery and pub.  Priding themselves on fresh and local ingredients, this is a must visit location.  The scratch made soups and carefully crafted cocktails are just a portion of the fabulous offerings. So, stop in and see what the buzz is about.

Goat Soup and Whiskey Location

The Goat is on Catawba Road between Mother of Sorrows Catholic Church and Heineman’s Winery.  This location is less than one half mile to downtown Put-in-Bay.  Also, surrounding this property is the beautiful Coopers Woods. Coopers Woods is a tract of wooded land that has remained natural for generations.  Lovely walking trails grace the space.  Wildflowers and wildlife alike are teeming here. read more

Quick Info:
820 Catawba Ave, Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456, United States
419-285-4628

Hooligans

hooligans irish pub

Hooligans Irish Pub is a lively eatery on the magical isle of Put-in-Bay.  Here, patrons can get the taste and feel of “The Emerald Isle. The Irish hospitality is worthy of a visit. Most importantly, the staff strives to provide an excellent dining experience.  Stop in for a pint.

Hooligans Location

The location of Hooligans is on Catawba Ave.  Furthermore, the Put-in-Bay Town Hall and Put-in-Bay Police Department are directly next door.  So, from this location guests are close to the action.

Inside, the interior is beautiful. Impressive wood working is found throughout.  The rich woods and Irish themed decor set the mood for a memorable experience.  There are multiple seating areas available.  Moreover, diners can choose the main dining room for table side service.  Otherwise, guests can opt to sit at the bar.  Lastly,  the lovely outside patio is a great option. From this vista, guests will have a front seat to the action. Catawba Avenue is oftentimes very busy, with golf carts whizzing by.  People watching at its finest. read more

Quick Info:
421 Catawba Avenue, Put-in-Bay, OH, United States
419-285-8000

Joe’s Bar & Restaurant

joes bar and restaurant

Joe’s Bar and Restaurant is a local favorite hangout.  The atmosphere is inviting, putting patrons at ease.  Guests can expect to leave refreshed from Joe’s.

Finding the location is easy.  Joe’s is located on the corner of Meechen Road and Catawba Avenue.  South Bass Island State Park is a short walk away.  The building is very distinguishable with a striking red exterior.  Moreover, the structure has a rich and lively history.  Previously, the space was used as a press house for grapes.  The wine making traditions of Put-in-Bay run deep.  Here, the Doller press house, was integral in the wine production.  Today, Heineman’s Winery continues the tradition. read more

Quick Info:
1400 Catawba Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456, United States
419-285-5637

The Keys

the keys put in bay

The Keys Restaurant brings Florida to Put-in-Bay.  Key West is well represented at this waterfront restaurant.  So, slow down and enjoy the island breezes.

A waterfront location makes the Keys an excellent choice.  Located in downtown Put-in-Bay next to the Jet Express Put in Bay dock, it is easy to find. Also, Perry’s Victory and International Peace Memorial is within view.  Moreover, this monument relates to the Battle of Lake Erie.  Oliver Hazard Perry was victorious, protecting the island from invasion.  Additionally, the monument serves as a testament to the ever lasting peace between the countries. read more

Quick Info:
227 Bayview Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH, United States
419-285-5397

Little Galley

little galley restaurant

The Little Galley on Put-in-Bay is part of the Boardwalk family of restaurants.  Families should take note of this eatery.  Morevoer, they feature affordable dining options for a trip to the island.

A waterfront location affords guests of the Little Galley exceptional views.  Furthermore, the Boardwalk Restaurant is located on Bayview Avenue in downtown Put-in-Bay.  Panoramic views of Lake Erie, the downtown docks and DeRivera Park abound.  Also, boaters can visit via the mooring buoys.  So, there are several options to make your way.

Little Galley Menu Highlights

This is the place to go for a quick and affordable lunch.  Moreover, menu highlights include classic Americana fare.  Black Angus burgers, chicken tenders and hot dogs are notable choices.  Also, piping hot french fries are served.  Add some zest to your meal with a selection of dipping sauces. read more

Quick Info:
341 Bayview Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH, United States
419-285-3695

Lolas Key

lolaskey

Lola’s Key at the Keys Restaurant complex features a gorgeous waterfront setting on Lake Erie.  Enjoy the lake breezes while enjoying a Fat Tuesday brand frozen concoction.  The Keys is the only establishment to offer these popular beverages.

Lola’s Key Location

After stepping off the Jet Express ferry, Lola’s Key is directly to the left of the dock.  There is ample seating at the bar and at tables perched just feet from the water.  Also, take in spectacular views of Perry’s Monument from this location.  Grab a savory appetizer and tasty beverage while enjoying the lovely setting.  From here, guests can traverse across DeRivera Park to the downtown Put-in-Bay area.  Here, most of the great attractions and shopping choices are found.  Stop in at Lola’s Key for great eats and stunning vistas. read more

Quick Info:
227 Bayview Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456, United States
(419) 285-5397

Unique Put-in-Bay Dining and Cuisine

When you explore the Lake Erie Islands, local authentic cuisine will be discovered all over. Meals ranging from simple fresh lake fish enjoyed with a view of the Bay to high-end but casual restaurants like the Goat Soup and Whiskey and everything you would expect in between. You could eat in a different Put-in-Bay dining for every meal. You might ask yourself, Can you make reservations for Put-in-Bay Restaurants? Well, most of our dining choices are walk-in and no reservations are needed!

Superb Lake Erie game fish like walleye and perch is typical – you’ll get no fresher in the classiest restaurants in the world. Island entertainment in the evening is a must: beautiful dancing, traditional island guitar acts and mesmerizing steel drums. The crowd participation with the popular late-night DJs in our Put-in-Bay clubs and bars is a highlight. How many bars are in Put-in-Bay Ohio? Well over a dozen!

Seafood and Concerts

Surrounded by Lake Erie, the shallowest of the Great Lakes, local fishermen venture beyond the lighthouse before sunrise. Their catches help Put-in-Bay Dining earn a reputation for creating the best cuisine in the area. Fresh seafood comes straight out of the lake and is prepared simply by local chefs. They use delicious local ingredients from our nutrient-rich fresh island gardens. Many island chefs even grow their own herbs and vegetables for a truly Green dining experience. But don’t worry, there are quick service places serving great food to diners like Subway and the Chicken Patio, and the Burrito Stand.

You can even get some fair food at the annual Bash on the Bay country concert in Put n Bay Ohio. Past performers have been Toby Keith Put in Bay, Rascal Flatts Put in Bay, and Kid Rock Put in Bay tickets. Local hotels offer their own unique food offerings also such as the Islander Inn Put in Bay and the Bayshore Resort Put in Bay. And as an added bonus, if you book direct (instead of using Airbnb Put in Bay or VRBO Put in Bay), then you will usually save money that you can use for great dining on the island!

Love fresh food?

There are over forty places to eat and drink on the little island of Put-in-Bay. This page features just a few! Also check out more dining options at PutinbayDining.com. Or simply ask a Put-in-Bay taxi driver where he or she loves to eat, you may be surprised!

Seafood meals at the Boardwalk feature favorite local dishes like famous lobster bisque cooked in a traditional manner and served in a sourdough bread bowl. Try Hooligans on Catawba Ave for the freshest perch tacos on the island. Lake Erie Perch is a favorite at Mossbacks across from Derivera Park. Alaskan King Crab entrees makes an appearance when it is in season.

Breakfast, Lunch, and Dinner

Where to get Breakfast on Put-in-Bay? Start the day with a delicious breakfast of Eggs Benedict at Frosty Bar or Bloody Marys at Reel Bar. Or maybe try the omelets at Pasquale’s Cafe on Loraine Ave or crepes at the Forge. The Village Bakery is a hot spot for danishes and coffee unless you favor the margaritas across the street with live entertainment. Ice cream at Dairy Isle is always an option, any time of day.

A perfect lunch in downtown Put-in-Bay can be a simple burger and fries at the Boathouse Bar or a cuban sandwich at Topsy Turvey. Late-night street vendor dogs or Cameo pizza slices in Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grille on Delaware Ave, or even a fine restaurant menu and appetizers at Upper Deck but in a casual environment like Mama Marias (famous for their meatball subs). What is the number for Pizza on Put-in-Bay? Your best bet for late night free delivery is 419-285-4444.

As well as gourmet sandwiches, pizza and Caribbean conch fritters are on offer by the water’s edge, there are many colorful cafés serving light meals and your fix of great eatery coffee. Is there a brewery on Put-in-Bay? Yes, there is, and it called the Put-in-Bay Brewery! There is even a distillery at the Put-in-Bay Brewery with outdoor seating.

After Hours at Put-in-Bay

When the sun sets and you’ve had your fill of our delicious cuisine. The real party begins! There are plenty of things to do in Put-in-Bay.

When the sun goes down, the party heats up. Put-in-Bay restaurants and bars boast the best nightlife of all the Lake Erie islands. Mix with friendly locals and boaters in open-air bars, most on the downtown strip where cool island vibes and spectacular vistas await. Grab a drink and enjoy the bands, whether local live music or a stunning sunset over the water at the Keys or Boardwalk restaurant.

When you want to go large, head to one of our pumping nightclubs, or join a nightly Put-in-Bay Rolling Pub Tour where you pedal yourself to the party. Above all, while our Put-in-Bay Restaurant nightlife is exciting and exotic, it’s extremely safe and fun. Stay Overnight and enjoy the late-night festivities!