The All-Star Ohio House

buckeye house

All-Star Ohio House

Spacious new Put-in-Bay Victorian rental home remodeled over the winter a few years ago! With 5 separated bedrooms and 3 full baths, this is an ‘open-feel’ home. Large master suite with sitting area offers a queen bed and a unique oversize private bath with tub and shower, enclosed for privacy, of course. Add four more bedrooms, each with queen size beds, and able to rented separately for a total of 22 people. Sheets, towels and linens are provided for all rooms.

This Ohio Sports themed home features extra seating in living room to watch the big game on a 60″ TV. Home includes free cable/sat with Wifi available. Front of home courtyard area has beautiful mosaic concrete pad with some Put-in-Bay lake view down through the park. Only 200 feet away from the main strip! Screened in front porch and large front and rear decks accommodate your leisure time. Gas BBQ and corn hole in private backyard. Parking available. Centrally located with full VIP access to the Put-in-Bay Resort and the island’s most popular swim up bar and world’s largest Jacuzzi.


Mike M: “Rented this for our group of 18 and what a blast. We were greeted by one of the owners and given the “rules speech” which was pretty basic, don’t trash the place, keep the noise reasonable and do not exceed the occupancy the house is rated for. All pretty straight forward stuff. We were given our wristbands which identify who is supposed to be on the property, kind of nice that they had security in the area to keep the riff raff out. We cooked out on the BBQ grill which was provided, and played corn hole and kind of hung out on the porch and people watched the first day. The house was very clean, and the location cannot be beat with just a one minute walk and you are at the Round House Bar! Overall this is a great place if you just follow the basic rules and show some respect. We booked for 2018 upon departure!”

Mike H: “Very nice home and location. Read in a previous review about people upset because they had to many people. We were told at the time of booking that it was a max 22 people so it was not a big deal as we were all adults and followed the rules. The house was clean, and the location was great literally 30 yards from the strip. We would repeat!”

Martin M: “GREAT location! We had previously stayed at rental homes in the center of the island but it was just too much of a hassle to taxi back and forth so we tried this place. They had corn hole boards and a BBQ grill for our group and the owner was fun and helpful. We have already booked for next year!”

Online Booking & Availability

The All-Star Ohio House has its own website located at but you can also call them at 1-888-742-7829.

Quick Info:
394 Loraine Ave, Put-in-Bay, Ohio 43456, United States