Put-In-Bay Lodging

When it comes to lodging, there’s a lot to choose from at Put-in-Bay, and sometimes it can get a little overwhelming. Do you want the standard hotel experience, or would you prefer a vacation rental to feel a little more at home? Do you want to be in the hectic downtown area, or a little off of the beaten path? Whatever it is that you seek, there are enough Put-in-Bay hotels, cottages and vacation rentals to find exactly what you need.

PIB Peace and Quiet

Peace And Quiet rental home

Peace & Quiet

Peace and Quiet is a lovely vacation rental on  Put-in-Bay. BOOK ONLINE QUICKLY! Here, guests can enjoy there own piece of the island.  The lovely wooded lot is the perfect setting for an enjoyable stay.

There are two units at Peace and Quiet.  Each efficiency can sleep up to 8 guests.  Additionally, each unit has a kitchen, dining area and air conditioning.  Also, a connecting porch is the perfect spot for morning coffee.  The large yard is also very usable.  Guests can bring yard games such as corn hole and have plenty of space to spread out.  Also, a propane grill is provided.  Take advantage of this feature and save your group a bundle during your Put-in-Bay stay.  Cooking just a couple meals can equate to great savings. read more


The All-Star Ohio House

buckeye house

All-Star Ohio House

Spacious new Put-in-Bay Victorian rental home remodeled over the winter a few years ago! With 5 separated bedrooms and 3 full baths, this is an ‘open-feel’ home. Large master suite with sitting area offers a queen bed and a unique oversize private bath with tub and shower, enclosed for privacy, of course. Add four more bedrooms, each with queen size beds, and able to rented separately for a total of 22 people. Sheets, towels and linens are provided for all rooms.

This Ohio Sports themed home features extra seating in living room to watch the big game on a 60″ TV. Home includes free cable/sat with Wifi available. Front of home courtyard area has beautiful mosaic concrete pad with some Put-in-Bay lake view down through the park. Only 200 feet away from the main strip! Screened in front porch and large front and rear decks accommodate your leisure time. Gas BBQ and corn hole in private backyard. Parking available. Centrally located with full VIP access to the Put-in-Bay Resort and the island’s most popular swim up bar and world’s largest Jacuzzi. read more


Ahoy Inn Bed and Breakfast

Ahoy Inn Bed and Breakfast is located just outside the downtown area. It is near restaurants and other attractions on Put-in-Bay. However, even with it being this close to the downtown area, Ahoy Inn is able to offer a quiet getaway that only accepts reservations from couples. As a result, it all adds up to a relaxing experience.

With the best island location, Ahoy Inn Guesthouse offers charming European themed and upscale island style rooms, all with a king bed, private bathroom, TV, fridge, WiFi, and AC. Guests can enjoy complimentary bicycles and golf cart rental on site. Only 2 minute walk to downtown shopping, dining, and entertainment. Please, visit Ahoy Inn’s website and Facebook page for current specials, photos, guest comments, and a full listings of amenities. Friendly innkeepers will make your island getaway special and memorable! read more


Great Put-in-Bay Lodging

If you’re looking for a Put-in-Bay resort in the center of the downtown area, you should consider the Commodore Resort or the Put-in-Bay Resort. Staying at the Commodore grants you access to MIST Pool Bar, and staying at the Put-in-Bay Resort gets you into Blue Marlin, collectively two of the best of the Put-in-Bay swim up bars.

This is something that Put-in-Bay is very well known for, and you’ll definitely want to make a pool bar a part of your trip. At the Commodore, you’ll also be right next door to Mr. Ed’s, one of the island’s most famous hotspots. Most vacations to the island involve visiting some of the Put-in-Bay bars and pubs, and one of the best is right on your doorstep!

There is even a Put-in-Bay taxi service to get you to the downtown area.

Off Put-in-Bay’s Beaten Path

Maybe you’d like something just a little quieter, perhaps for a romantic getaway with your husband or wife, boyfriend or girlfriend. Consider then

the Victory Station Hotel. This boutique hotel is the perfect spot for a couple to relax and unwind for a weekend. Only a few steps from downtown, next to the Put-in-Bay Golf Cart Depot, you’ll be just a stone’s throw away from all of the dining and shopping on offer on the main strip. However, you’ll also be detached enough that you can have quiet peaceful romantic moments.

Put-in-Bay Vacation Rentals

Put-in-Bay is also a famous group destination, and if you’re bringing a group, it’s time to start looking at vacation rentals. Your Put-in-Bay bachelorette party, bachelor party or family reunion will be so much better with everyone under one roof, and you can make that happen at the Island Club or Put-in-Bay Condos.

The Island Club and Put-in-Bay Condos

The Island Club is a Put-in-Bay legend, offering home rentals on the island for decades. If you’re a South Bass Island regular, chances are you stay at the Island Club. There’s a reason they have so many repeat customers. An Island Club rental offers all the amenities of home at a price per person that you just can’t beat at Put-in-Bay. With over 70 properties available, you’ll be able to find the perfect fit for your group.

The Put-in-Bay Condos are right up against the water by the Put-in-Bay Airport, providing astonishing views of Lake Erie. The Waterfront Condos are the newest place to stay at Put-in-Bay, and each has its own private patio for you to enjoy the view you richly deserve!

There are also the original Put-in-Bay Poolview Condos for those on a budget!

More Choices Than You Can Imagine

This is only scratching the surface of what’s available to you at the Bay. You could also check out places like Bay Lodging or the Put-in-Bay Villas, or smaller individual properties like the All-Star Ohio House or A Place at the Bay.

The Next Step to Booking Your Put-in-Bay Vacation

As you can see, there’s a lot to consider. You can’t go wrong with any of the places mentioned above, but there are also some great individual specialty properties to consider. Click on a property above to learn more, and give us a call at 216-898-9951 if you have any questions about an individual accommodation on our site, we are here to help!